A/76/136
16. Resort may be had to countermeasures in response to an internationally
wrongful act, in accordance with international law, in relation to States’ activities in
cyberspace as in relation to their other activities. This includes both resorting to
countermeasures against a State whose cyber activities constitute internationally
wrongful acts and carrying out countermeasures by means of cyber operations.
Countermeasures need not be symmetrical: where the internationally wrongful act is
itself not a cyber activity, the response may nonetheless involve cyber-based
countermeasures (and vice versa).
17. An injured State may only take countermeasures against a State which is
responsible for an internationally wrongful act in order to induce that State to comply
with its obligations. Any measures adopted must be commensurate with the injury
suffered. They must be carried out in accordance with the conditions and restrictions
established in international law and must in particular not contravene the prohibition
on the threat or use of force, must be necessary and proportionate to the purpose of
inducing the responsible State to comply with its obligations and must not contravene
any other peremptory norm of international law.
18. The application of international law to the use of countermeasures in
cyberspace must take account of the nature of cyber activities, which might
commence and then cease almost instantaneously or within a short timeframe. In
those circumstances, a wider pattern of cyber activities might collectively constitute
an internationally wrongful act justifying a response.
19. The UK does not consider that States taking countermeasures are legally
obliged to give prior notice (including by calling on the State responsible for the
internationally wrongful act to comply with international law) in all circumstances.
Prior notice may not be a legal obligation when responding to covert cyber intrusion
with countermeasures or when resort is had to countermeasures which themselves
depend on covert cyber capabilities. In such cases, prior notice could expose highly
sensitive capabilities and prejudice the very effectiveness of the countermeasures in
question. However any decision to resort to countermeasures without prior notice
must be necessary and proportionate to the purpose of inducing compliance in the
circumstances.
INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS LAW
20. Human rights obligations apply to States’ activities in cyberspace as they do to
in relation to their other activities. The UK continues to support the view set out in
Human Rights Council Resolution 20/8 that ‘the same rights that people have offline
must also be protected online…’. States have an obligation to act in accordance with
applicable international human rights law, including customary international law, and
international conventions to which they are a party, such as the International Covenant
on Civil and Political Rights, other UN treaties, and regional instruments such as the
European Convention on Human Rights.
21. States’ respect for their human rights obligations in relation to their activities
in cyberspace is essential to ensuring an open, secure, stable, accessible and peaceful
environment and certain rights may have particular relevance to States’ activities in
cyberspace including the right not to be subjected to arbitrary or unlawful interference
with privacy, family, home or correspondence, the right to freedom of thought,
conscience and religion and the right to freedom of expression.
INTERNATIONAL HUMANITARIAN LAW (IHL)
22. IHL applies to operations in cyberspace conducted in the furtherance of
hostilities in armed conflict just as it does to other military operations.
118/142
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents