62
Compendium: High Level Review of United Nations Sanctions
B. UN sanctions and arms/non-proliferation/
export control arrangements
The imposition and implementation of restrictive measures in the arms and
non-proliferation fields present particular challenges because of technical
complexities and political sensitivities. The requisite expertise can be found
both inside and outside the UN, depending on the subject matter. Sanctions
coexist with international organizations and other regulatory instruments,
including export control arrangements, which may or may not be global in
scope or coverage. These existing frameworks require the establishment of
regulatory agencies and control systems at the national level, but they do not
necessarily encompass specific UN restrictive measures. National regulatory agencies and private sector actors must comply with existing regulatory
frameworks, as well as with specific restrictive measures required by relevant
sanctions regimes.
Consultations indicated that formal reliance on implementation guidance developed outside UN settings, particularly in fora with restricted
membership such as the FATF or export control regimes, would be sensitive.
It was recognised, however, that the UN should, and in fact at times does,
seek knowledge and inspiration from work done elsewhere so as to obtain
the requisite and up-to-date expertise.
Participants also noted that definitional and methodological work
in one area could benefit implementation efforts in another, which should
prompt synergies to the extent possible. The degree to which non-UN
organizations and arrangements could meet demands for interaction with
the UNSC and its bodies and the Secretariat would of course ultimately
depend on governing bodies’ approval.
Some definitional issues relevant for this cluster of items are dealt with
above in section VII.A.4. This section outlines recommendations derived
from more specific issues.
1.
Cooperation between UN sanctions and relevant arms/
export control regimes and cross-cutting treatment
of subject-matter
Rather than being confined to particular sanctions regimes and restrictive
measures, sanctions implementation efforts should increasingly be crosscutting. Export control and other arms-related regimes have developed fieldtested practices, definitions, and mechanisms that could enhance UN sanctions implementation in relevant fields. Mutually advantageous cooperation
should be sought, building on the model established by the 1540 Committee.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents