66
3.
Compendium: High Level Review of United Nations Sanctions
Over-compliance with financial sanctions
As discussed by several HLR working groups, targeted sanctions can have
unintended consequences. Some private sector actors, confused by differing
unilateral, regional, and UN sanctions, or generally risk-averse and aiming
at minimising implementation costs, apply policies resulting in over-compliance (including foregoing legitimate business with entities not subject to
UN sanctions, or even all business with a particular country). Humanitarian
actors have noted the role of sanctions in dissuading donors’ from providing
aid to certain regions (see section VI.D), regardless of who is targeted or
what derogations may be available. Promoting a clear understanding of the
requirements of UN sanctions is important to limit unintentionally broad
interpretations of the scope of UN sanctions and unintended consequences.
92. DPA should prepare and disseminate guidance translating UN sanctions
financial requirements into understandable actionable measures for implementation, including as appropriate the availability of exemptions.
93. Sanctions committees and expert groups should conduct outreach to raise
awareness regarding the specific requirements of UN sanctions with private
sector groups and to understand in greater detail risk factors and data-protection and privacy concerns which may contribute to over-compliance.
94. The UN through DPA, relevant sanctions committees, and expert groups
should be prepared to participate in international discussions such as are
foreseen within FATF in the coming years on risk aversion and de-risking.
95. The Secretariat should conduct a dialogue with the FATF on minimising the
impact of national sanctions on humanitarian assistance. The Secretariat
and FATF should develop guidance on implementation measures that
strike a balance between mitigating the risk of diversion of aid and safeguarding the ability of humanitarian actors to respond to humanitarian
crises, while maintaining their neutrality and impartiality.
D. UN sanctions and international criminal justice
proceedings
UN sanctions increasingly target perpetrators of conduct that could be considered as crimes within the jurisdiction of the ICC or other courts—genocide,
crimes against humanity, and war crimes, including attacks against civilians,
recruitment of child soldiers, and sexual and gender based violence, as well as
serious violations of human rights. In some cases the same individuals could
be subject to both court proceedings and UN sanctions. The possibility of
sanctions or sanctions-related investigations negatively affecting international
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents