A/76/136
Department of Defense’s Law of War Manual, reflecting a commitment to ensure that
U.S. legal obligations are understood and respected by its military. 286 Several other
States have taken similar steps to share their views on how international humanitarian
law applies and / or address cyber specifically in their military manuals. 287
For example, in the context of jus ad bellum, it is important for States to
understand what types of activities would be interpreted by other States as violations
of Article 2(4) or that might prompt a State to invoke its right of self-defense under
Article 51. Similarly, it is important for States to develop clear understandings of the
restrictions that the Charter and customary international law place on this type of
conduct; for example, even where a State may lawfully use force in self-defense, its
response must be necessary and proportionate to respond to an actual or imminent
armed attack. The United States has sought to be transparent about its views in this
regard, including through its submissions to this and previous GGEs, and would
encourage other States to do the same.
Similarly, international humanitarian law regulates the conduct of hostilities to
minimize their effects on civilians and avoid unnecessary suffering. It does so in part
through specific protections for civilians and civilian objects. Understanding how
these protections apply in the context of cyber attacks is particularly important, given
the often dual-use nature of ICT infrastructure and interconnectivity of ICTs.
Affirmation that this body of law applies is consistent with our common commitment
to the pursuit of peace.
III. Application of International Law to Cyber Activities Below the Level of a Use
of Force
A. Respect for the sovereign equality of States and human rights
As recognized in the 2013 and 2015 GGE reports, State sovereignty and the
international principles that flow from sovereignty apply to States’ ICT-related
activities and to their jurisdiction over ICT infrastructure within their territory. 288
The United States believes that State sovereignty, among other long-standing
international legal principles, must be taken into account in the conduct of activities
in cyberspace. Whenever a State contemplates conducting activities in cyberspace,
the equal sovereignty of other States needs to be considered.
The implications of sovereignty for cyber activities are complex, but we can
start by noting two important implications of sovereignty for ICT-related activities.
First, we acknowledge the continuing relevance of territorial jurisdiction, even to
cyber activities, and second, we acknowledge the exercise of jurisdiction by the
territorial State is not unlimited; it must also be consistent with applicable
international law, including international human rights obligations.
Among other international legal principles, the 2015 GGE report acknowledges
the principle of non-intervention in the internal affairs of other States. 289 As
articulated by the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in its judgment on the merits in
the Nicaragua Case, this rule of customary international law forbids States from
__________________
286
287
288
289
21-09670
Department of Defense, Law of War Manual, § 16, available at: https://dod.defense.gov/Portals/
1/Documents/pubs/DoD%20Law%20of%20War%20Manual%20-%20June%202015%20Updated
%20Dec%202016.pdf?ver=2016-12-13-172036-190.
See note 285 supra; see also Danish Ministry of Defense, Military Manual on International Law
Relevant to Danish Armed Forces in International Operations, § 3.10, Regulation of Computer
Network Operations in international law (12 Oct. 2020), available at: https://forsvaret.dk/en/
publications/military-manual/.
2013 GGE Report, para. 20; 2015 GGE Report, para. 27.
2015 GGE Report, para. 26.
139/142
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents