Any interpretation of the use of force in cyberspace should respect the UN Charter and not just
the letter of the Charter but also its object and purpose, which is to prevent the escalation of
armed activities. This would mean, for instance, that the distinction between armed attack as a
particularly serious violation of the Charter, on the one hand, and any lesser uses of force, on the
other, is preserved. Similarly, the conditions for the exercise of the right of self-defence apply in
cyberspace as they do with regard to the use of armed force. The right of self-defence arises if a
cyberattack comparable to an armed attack occurs and can be attributed to a particular State.24
It is reasonable to think that a State victim to such an attack can respond with either cyber means
or armed action. At the same time, the use of force must not be disproportionate or excessive.
International Humanitarian Law
International humanitarian law only applies to cyber operations when such operations are part
of, or amount to, an armed conflict. Most so far known cyberattacks have not been launched in
the context of an armed conflict or met the threshold of armed conflict. At the same time, when
cyber means are used in the context of a pre-existing armed conflict, as has been done in many
current conflicts, there is no reason to deny the need for the protections that international
humanitarian law provides.
This includes that cyber means and methods of warfare must be used consistently with the
principles of distinction, proportionality and precautions, as well as the specific rules flowing from
these principles. When assessing the capacity of cyber means and methods to cause prohibited
harm, their foreseeable direct and indirect effects shall be taken into account. Constant care shall
be taken to ensure the protection of civilians and civilian objects, including essential civilian
infrastructure, civilian services and civilian data.
The unique characteristics of cyberspace, such as interconnectedness and anonymity, may affect
how international humanitarian law is interpreted and applied with regard to certain cyber
means and methods warfare. The related problems can nevertheless mostly be solved on the
basis of existing rules. New technologies do not render the existing rules of international
humanitarian law meaningless or necessarily require new legal regulation. Furthermore, while
international humanitarian law is lex specialis in an armed conflict, it does not override other
areas of international law, such as human rights law, which may continue to apply throughout
the conflict.
Human rights law
A number of specific human rights such as the freedom of opinion and expression, including the
right to access to information, and the right to privacy are particularly relevant in cyberspace. It
should nevertheless be underlined that individuals enjoy the same international human rights
24
While the possibility of a cyberattack rising to the level of an armed attack without the involvement of any State
is conceivable, the related questions of self-defence against non-State actors are too complicated to be discussed
here.
7
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents