The argument has been raised recently that no legal consequences could be attached to sovereignty as a general principle, at least for the purposes of cyber activities. It is not only difficult to reconcile such an idea with the established status of the rule prohibiting violations of sovereignty in international law but it also gives rise to policy concerns. Agreeing that a hostile cyber operation below the threshold of prohibited intervention cannot amount to an internationally wrongful act would leave such operations unregulated and deprive the target State of an important opportunity to claim its rights. Finland sees sovereignty as a primary rule of international law, a breach of which amounts to an internationally wrongful act and triggers State responsibility. This rule is fully applicable in cyberspace. Whether an unauthorized cyber intrusion violates the target State’s sovereignty depends on its nature and consequences and is subject to a case-by-case assessment. Illegal intervention A hostile interference by cyber means may also breach the customary prohibition of intervention in the internal affairs of another State, provided that it is done with the purpose of compelling or coercing that State in relation to affairs regarding which it has free choice (so-called domaine réservé). The requirement of coercion leaves out lesser forms of influence and persuasion that are commonplace in international relations. The limitation to sovereign affairs – such as a State’s political, economic or cultural system or the direction of its foreign policy12 – further distinguishes prohibited intervention from measures, the purpose of which is to compel another State to comply with its international obligations. For a cyber operation to amount to a prohibited intervention, both above-mentioned elements must be present. Most open questions relate to the element of coercion and to how it manifests itself in cyber operations. For instance, while the conduct of elections belongs undisputedly to the internal affairs of each State, all methods of electoral interference do not display the element of coercion.13 Hacking of voter databases or manipulation of vote counts in order to alter the election results has nevertheless been recognized as a fairly clear case. To be comparable to a real world intervention, cyber interference must also be of a serious nature. According to the International Court of Justice, the element of coercion is particularly clear if force is used through means of military action, threats of such action, or through support to armed groups in another State. 14 Military or economic pressure may also qualify as coercion. Hostile cyber interference done with the purpose of promoting or supporting armed action in another State could constitute an example of prohibited intervention, provided that it seeks to force a certain policy change.15 12 Military and Paramilitary Activities in and against Nicaragua, para. 205. All methods of electoral interference are not coercive, see EU vs. disinfo, 10 Methods of electoral interference (2019). 14 Military and Paramilitary Activities in and against Nicaragua, para.247. 15 Ibid., see also paras 241 and 242. See also Friendly Relations Declaration, UN Doc. A/RES/2625(XXV). 13 3

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents