To obtain cybercrime evidence, collaborating with third parties, such as ISPs,55 is vital, as
considerable amounts of evidence of cybercriminal activity are stored in information systems
managed by third parties. In order to prevent law enforcement from overstepping its powers in
such data acquisition, it is important to clearly define what type of information might be acquired,
as well as the procedures for requesting and, if necessary, compelling third parties to release that
information. Various factors—including where the ISPs are located (both their servers and other
hardware), available legal mechanisms and terms and conditions of user agreement—will determine
the tone of the third-party cooperation.56 As significant human rights considerations surround such
activities, especially around the freedom of communication, it is incumbent upon both law makers
and authorities to implement laws and regulations appropriately balancing government power
with individual rights. These matters are discussed in greater depth below (see section 4 A, and 4 B
below).
It is important to realize that not all data is the same, and, as such, that there may be varying
degrees of potential privacy considerations, for example. It is also important to distinguish between
areas where voluntary cooperation may be appropriate as opposed to situations where third parties
are compelled to cooperate with law enforcement. Both are discussed below.
Three different classes of stored communication should be differentiated:
1 Subscriber information;
2 Communication records or logs; and
3 Communication content.
Subscriber information is relatively basic, pertaining to identifying information such as the
subscriber’s name, contact and payment details. Such information is typically needed by
investigative authorities in order to make requests to obtain warrants and other public requests.
Attaining subscriber information—the first type of data—typically implicates fewer privacy concerns
than does seeking access to the content of communications, and, as such, this information
is generally subject to fewer safeguards and limitations. To facilitate investigations while also
protecting individual privacy, laws should further distinguish between basic customer information
and information detailing account activity.
The second class of data, communication records or logs, are more detailed, and includes IP
address(es) of device(s) used by person(s) under investigation, time of transmitting and receiving
electric communications, data volume, communication ports, protocol information and the like. As
acquiring this information is a significantly greater infringement of privacy, the law should clearly
define and delineate both the scope of communication records that might be acquired and the
procedures for doing so. Typically, court orders are issued on the basis of “reasonable grounds”
showing that the communication record is relevant to the investigation in progress. Moreover,
these laws frequently require that, upon completion of the investigation or the prosecution, the
investigative agency notify the investigated party of the data acquisition. That said, in some
Page 103 | Chapter 2 | § C. Procedural Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents