Conclusion
Traditional search and seizure procedures focus on the collection of physical evidence. However,
e-evidence has different properties, requiring different search and seizure approaches, which must
be dictated by the legal framework. Careful attention must be paid to creating procedures that
accommodate the difference between digital information and digital storage devices, and which
respect fundamental rights, notably the right to privacy, by limiting the scope of the search and
seizure, as prescribed by the warrant. In many jurisdictions, judicial bodies have been attentive to
excluding information as evidence of guilt where it has been illegally gathered as beyond the scope
of the warrant.
Third parties are often essential to the collection of evidence. In order to collect communication
data managed by third party (e.g., subscriber information, communication records, communication
content), and to do so in real-time, appropriate procedures need to be implemented directing
those parties to offer technical and administrative support to law enforcement. Moreover, ISPs
not only store subscribers’ data but also have their own technologies and metadata that are of
value to law enforcement. Procedures obliging ISPs to cooperate with law enforcement should
be based on (1) the classification of requests for data preservation; (2) the acquisition of the
stored communication data; and (3) the real-time collection of communication data. Provisions
guaranteeing ISPs exemptions from both civil and criminal liabilities that could arise out of third
parties’ provision of data should accompany such procedures. Procedures obliging ISPs to
cooperate must also strike an appropriate balance between respecting fundamental rights and
accounting for cyberspace’s rapidly evolving nature.
Rapid technological advancements, notably cloud computing, make create an ever-evolving
technological morass through which law enforcement must seek to navigate. The development of
cloud computing requires also a legal development with respect to the procedures for search and
seizure. Moreover, even once technological obstructions have been surmounted, jurisdictional ones
often persist given the disparate physical that support the existence of cyberspace; such issues
require an ever-greater push to create a shared, international consensus, if not a single vision. As
discussed further on (see section 5, below), it is important to establish corresponding procedural
safeguards to protect personal data and privacy rights, as well as to the define limits of procedural
powers utilized to investigate cybercrime and to gather e-evidence.
Page 108 | Chapter 2 | § C. Procedural Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents