challenges. This section (I) explores how best to assure the authenticity, integrity and
reliability of e-evidence, before turning to (II) understanding the “hearsay” rule as it
applies to e-evidence.
I. Computer Forensics
Computer forensics is not only necessary to establishing the appropriate proceedings by which
cybercrimes are investigated (see section 2 C, above), but also necessary to the collection of
e-evidence. To enter into such a discussion, it is important to consider (A) the nature of e-evidence
and (B) the nature of the corpus of law of evidence. On the basis of that understanding, (C) the role
of computer forensics can be discussed.
A. The Nature of e-Evidence
As with so much in cyberspace and cybercrime, there is no single definition of a term “digital” or
“electronic” evidence (“e-evidence”). For purposes of the Toolkit, the term will be used to refer to
“information stored or transmitted in binary form that may be relied in court”.3 E-evidence is used
as a proof of crime in the same way as physical evidence. Indeed, beyond “pure” cybercrimes, the
development of cyber services and the widespread supply of ICT devices have led to increased use
of e-evidence in prosecuting traditional, physical-world crimes.
Digital information is electronic by definition and by nature, and therefore has a “virtual” and
“imaged” existence. As such, and unlike physical evidence, digital information is not “fixed” to a
single device, meaning that it can be easily copied and reproduced onto another device without
any alteration or loss of information. However, as courts have generally required original evidence
when considering physical evidence, and only relatively rarely allow copies to be presented as
evidence, the ease and completeness with which digital data might be reproduced and transposed
has led to discussions about whether copies might, in fact, be presented as identical to the
“original” copy. By and large, it is impractical to present anything other than the copy of the original
e-evidence; indeed, as already discussed,4 sometimes taking a copy of the original digital data is
the only way that investigators can examine the often-vast array of information confronting them.
As e-evidence is effectively an electronic image constructed out of code, it is much more
susceptible to alternation than most physical evidence. Both intentional and unintended alterations
might occur if vigilance is not assured. As this vulnerability might lead to claims of unreliability, it is
especially critical that investigators assure and preserve the authenticity, integrity and reliability of
the original copy of e-evidence throughout the chain of custody, from collection, through analysis
and to submission to the court.
Page 110 | Chapter 2 | § D. Evidentiary Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents