In addition to such an exception, the Court has given several other exceptions to the general
applicability of the hearsay rule:
1 e-Evidence is not hearsay if digital file itself serves as a direct evidence of the offense.70
For instance, in texted phone messages creating fear or apprehension constitute direct
evidence of crime in some countries criminalizing cyberstalking (e.g., Korea);71 or child
pornography on a computer constitutes a direct evidence of crime in some countries (e.g.,
USA).72
2 e-Evidence is not hearsay if it is submitted to discredit the truthfulness of a statement, or
where it is circumstantial evidence to an indirect fact. For instance, evidence showing that a
certain file was run can be used as circumstantial evidence to indirect facts.73
3 e-Evidence that is automatically generated and which does not incorporate any thoughts
or emotions is not hearsay. For instance, network log records, web history, call history,
GPS navigation information, file meta-information, etc. are all admissible on a showing of
authenticity, integrity and reliability.74
Conclusion
Investigations must be prepared to turn into prosecutions if they are to have any effect. The
evidentiary record, upon which adjudication must turn, being developed from e-evidence,
specialized protocols and certifications ought to be developed. It is important that the established
procedures, recognize the unique nature of e-evidence, and assure its authenticity, integrity, and
reliability. In light of the fragility of e-evidence, law enforcement agencies must look for ways to
preserve e-evidence throughout the entirety of the investigatory and prosecution process, from
collection, through analysis and on to submission to court. Only trained and expert personnel,
with digital forensic expertise, should handle e-evidence. All personnel should work according to
established and standardized guidelines, procedures and protocols. Reliable, regularly-calibrated,
and tested tools and equipment should be used, and all evidence, for the entire chain of custody—
collection, analysis, submission and disposal—, should be uploaded to a central, online e-evidence
management system.
Consideration should be given as to whether international recognition of evidence could be best
facilitated by having an international body dedicated to developing certified training programs,
as well as standardized procedures and guidelines. Such a body might be established in a manner
similar to informal international information sharing and coordination centers (see section 4 B,
below). That body, which, for example, might be housed within INTERPOL75 or UNODC,76 could
Page 119 | Chapter 2 | § D. Evidentiary Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents