1 Prescriptive authority – that is, authority pertaining to the authority to impose laws;
2
Adjudicative authority – that is, authority pertaining to the authority to investigate and
resolve disputes; and
3 Enforceable authority – that is, authority pertaining to the power to induce or punish
pursuant to its prescriptive authority and subsequent to its adjudicative authority.
Typically, when speaking of a state having jurisdiction, it is with regard to all three of these facets
(although, in exercising its authority, a court may apply the laws of another jurisdiction3). Three
distinct areas of positive4 jurisdictional conflicts exist: jurisdiction over the crime, over the evidence
and over the perpetrator.
This section focuses principally on jurisdiction over the crime and then briefly on jurisdiction
over the perpetrator. Further discussion of jurisdiction over the perpetrator and jurisdiction over
evidence is discussed in sections covering procedural and evidentiary issues,5 and in those covering
the cross-border context.6 This section discusses (I) traditional understandings of jurisdiction and
(II) the adaptive jurisdictional principles that have emerged in international law. Thereafter, it turns
to consider attempts to overcome jurisdictional issues (III) at the national level before (IV) briefly
noting the utility of international instruments in extending that process.
I. The Traditional Notion of Jurisdiction
Jurisdiction of a state to criminalize an act has traditionally been based on its sovereign control
over the specific territory in question—what is known as the principle of territoriality.7 With such
territorial control, the state is theoretically in a position to exert jurisdiction in its fullest extent for
crimes occurring between people in that space, and to do so to the exclusion of all other powers:
as the German sociologist Max Weber put it, the defining characteristic of the modern state is
that it is a “human community that (successfully) claims the monopoly of the legitimate use of
physical force within a given territory”.8 However, the nature of cyberspace often makes such a
facile delineation of jurisdiction exceptionally difficult and even possibly nonsensical due to the
inherent mobility, difficulty in proving location and geographic irrelevance in executing cybercrimes.
Since a cybercrime can be perpetrated from entirely a country while having substantial effects
within another country’s borders, the traditional basis for jurisdiction has become inadequate, if not
irrelevant.
Box 2.6: Inability to Prosecute Creator of the “Love Bug” Virus
On 4 May 2000, the so-called “Love Bug” virus (duly named because it was spread by
opening an email bearing the title of “ILOVEYOU”) rapidly “hopscotched” around the
Page 122 | Chapter 2 | § E. Jurisdicational Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents