the basis for adopting statutes criminalizing extraterritorial behavior without regard to where or by
whom the act is committed.41 In the instance of the protective principle, neither perpetrator, nor
victim, nor the implicated infrastructure are necessarily within the state. Such a tenuous, even weak,
connection to the acting state, as well as to the significant,42 often (at least partially) preemptive
nature of the intrusion upon the sovereignty of the other state, makes extraterritorial exertions of
jurisdiction based on this principle particularly controversial, and, as a result, probably the least
used theory for sanctioning jurisdiction.43
E. Principle of Universal Jurisdiction
The principle of universal jurisdiction applies to specific crimes, but requires international—or
universal—consensus: this principle recognizes a sovereign’s right to adopt criminal laws restricting
the behavior, regardless of who commits it, or where it is committed, insofar as restricting that
conduct is recognized by nations as being of universal concern.44 Piracy on the high seas, regarded
as one of the first international crimes, is a classic example.45 The use of this principle in cybercrime
is limited because of the lack of consensus surrounding the criminality of cybercrimes.46 However,
and nonetheless, some states have extended universality to include certain cybercrimes—for
instance, the German where the criminal code authorizes its authorities to prosecute all crimes of
child pornography.47
III. National Frameworks
Regardless of whether international instruments are used to mitigate jurisdictional issues, national
legal frameworks (see sections 5 A, and 5 B, below) might be crafted so as to facilitate cooperation.
There are two means for a state to implement the above principles: either (A) by formally
authorizing adaptive jurisdictional definitions through legislation, or (B) by relying on investigatory
agencies to build relations—of varying degrees of formality—with their counterparts in other
states. Both options, though different, are of great importance and value, each allowing for faster
responses to concerns and better permitting the preservation of evidence.
A. Adaptive Legislative Jurisdictional Definitions
The first method that states might use to facilitate processes for obtaining jurisdiction over
cybercrimes occurring beyond their territory is to legislatively authorize adaptive jurisdictional
definitions discussed above.48 Doing so formally extents the state’s legal understanding of what
constitutes criminal acts, even if conducted beyond that state’s territory. In effect, it also puts wouldbe perpetrators on notice.
Page 126 | Chapter 2 | § E. Jurisdicational Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents