Even where formal instruments of international cooperation such as MLATs exist, informal
cooperation is often essential to the successful investigation and prosecution of cybercrime. Major
cybercrime cases frequently affect more than one country—for example, when administrators of
website selling stolen credit cards are arrested. In such cases, several states may be in a position
to exert jurisdiction. However, weighing the particularities and appropriateness is often beyond
the scope or means of MLATs. For instance, rather than take on the matter directly, the Budapest
Convention simply provides that, if appropriate, countries consult with each other to decide which
state should assert jurisdiction.58 At such a crossroads, informal understandings and relationships
often play a larger role in determining the expediency with which matters proceed. Indeed, when
more than one country is interested in a case, law authorities of the affected states will already be
collaborating before any turning point, such as an arrest, is reached. Thus, even if several countries
could claim jurisdiction, there may in fact be no dispute. These informal cooperative arrangements
are often the best milieu for considering which and whether targets will be tried in one country or
another (perhaps on the basis of which sentences are traditionally heavier), or on the order in which
prosecution and sentencing will occur.
IV. Multilateral Instruments
Where cybercriminal matters are concerned, negotiated multilateral instruments—rather than the
afore-discussed jurisdictional theories—are the most effective and important means of establishing
extra-territorial jurisdiction. International instruments are essential to combatting cybercrime as
jurisdictional issues arise frequently and in all forms. As such, international cooperation is crucial to
building effective, comprehensive legal frameworks to combat cybercrime.
While international cooperation comes in various forms, the two most common forms MLATs and
extradition treaties, both of which are discussed in greater depth further on (see section 5 A, below).
It bears noting that the issue of convergence of legislation is highly relevant, as a large number of
countries base their MLA regime on the principle of dual criminality.59
Conclusion
Although there are a number of offences that can be prosecuted anywhere in the world, regional
differences play an important role. Cybercrime offenses cannot be properly prosecuted within
the confines of traditional understandings of jurisdiction. Due to the transnational nature of
cybercrimes, states need to create means for investigating and prosecuting offenses which target
or affect them and which occur, or which are launched, from beyond their borders. Such begins by
developing comprehensive national legal frameworks. However, jurisdictional extensions meet,
and therefore must balance with, the sovereignty of other states. A diversity of legal bases exists
Page 128 | Chapter 2 | § E. Jurisdicational Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents