End Notes Referenced in: § A. Working Definition of Cybercrime 1. Brenner, “Thoughts, Witches and Crimes,” supra § 1 B, note 2. 2. “Cybercrime refers to any crime that can be committed by means of a computer system or network, in a computer system or network or against a computer system. In principle, it encompasses any crime capable of being committed in an electronic environment.” Background Paper for the Workshop on Crimes Related to the Computer Network, 10th UN Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders, (10–17 Apr. 2000) A/CONF.187/10, [hereafter, “UNODC Conference Paper”] p. 4, at https://www.unodc.org/documents/ congress//Previous_Congresses/10th_ Congress_2000/017_ACONF.187.10_Crim es_Related_to_Computer_Networks.pdf. 3. UN Secretariat, “Background Paper: Workshop 3 on Strengthening Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice Responses to Evolving Forms of Crime, Such as Cybercrime and Trafficking in Cultural Property, Including Lessons Learned and International Cooperation,” 13th UN Congress on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice, (2 Feb. 2015) A/ CONF.222/12, p. 6, at http://www.unodc .org/documents/congress/Docume ntation/A-CONF.222-12_Workshop3/ ACONF222_12_e_V1500663.pdf. 4. In addition, a cybercrime may be prosecutable under the general criminal code. A standard forgery statute may stretch to cover electronic forgery, theft via electronic systems may be covered by a standard theft statute, and so on. 5. 6. COMSEC, “Report of the Commonwealth Working Group on Experts on Cybercrime,” Meeting of Commonwealth Law Ministers and Senior Officials, Gaborone, Botswana (5–8 May 2014), Annex A, pp. 13–14, at http:// thecommonwealth.org/sites/default/files/ news-items/documents/Report_of_the_ Commonwealth_Working_Group_of_ Experts_on_Cybercrime_May_2014.pdf. 7. On the basis of the legal principle of nulla poena sine lege (Latin for “no penalty without a law”), it is generally understood that crimes must be defined with appropriate certainty (legal certainty) and definiteness (both in the committed act and the requisite mental state), and with appropriate notice given, in order for the rule of law to exist. 8. Generally speaking, laws are interpreted by courts according to their “plain” or “literal” meaning, by which judges are to read the letter of the law in a textual, word-for-word sense without diverting from its true meaning, with words given their plain, ordinary and literal meaning. See, e.g., United Kingdom: Fisher v Bell [1961] 1 QB 394; United States: Connecticut Nat’l Bank v. Germain, 112 S. Ct. 1146, 1149 (1992). The rule of “narrow” or “strict” construction of criminal statutes, the opposite of “liberal” or “broad” construction, means that a criminal statute may not be expanded by implication or intent beyond the fair meaning of the statute’s language; its corollary, the rule of lenity, holds that ambiguity should be resolved in the defendant’s favor. See, e.g., United States v. Granderson, 114 S. Ct. 1259, 1263 (1994). The result of this approach is that “when choice has to be made between two readings of what conduct [a legislature] has made a crime, it is appropriate, before [choosing] the harsher alternative, to require that [the legislature] should have spoken in language that is clear and definite.” Dowling v. United States, 473 U.S. 207, 214 (1985) (internal quotations and citations omitted). 9. Basic information on international and regional instruments on cybercrime is provided in appendix 9 A (Multilateral Instruments on Cybercrime). 10. Oxford English Dictionary. 11. UNODC Cybercrime Study, supra § 1 B, note 7. 12. See, e.g., Budapest Convention, supra § 1 B, note 32, at Art. 1.b. 13. Ibid. See also, ITU Understanding Cybercrime, supra § 1 B, note 1, at 11 & 41 (“For example, a person who produces USB devices containing malicious software that destroys data on computers when the device is connected commits a crime.”); UNODC Cybercrime Study, supra § 1 B, note 7 (“In practice, computer data or information likely includes data or information stored on physical storage media (such as hard disk drives, USB memory sticks or flash cards), [….]”). 14. See, e.g., League of Arab States, Arab Convention on Combatting Information Technology Offences (21 Dec. 2010), [hereafter, “Arab Convention”], Art. 2(6); Budapest Explanatory Report, supra § 1 D, note 14. 15. CoE’s Cybercrime Convention Committee (T-CY) notes that “the definition of ‘computer system’ in Article 1.a [of the Budapest Convention] covers developing forms of technology that go beyond traditional mainframe or desktop computer systems, such as modern mobile phones, smart phones, PDAs, tablets or similar”. “Guidance Note # 1: On the Notion of ‘Computer System’: Art. 1.a, Budapest Convention,” adopted by the T-CY at its 8th Plenary, (5 Dec. 2012) CoE, T-CY at https://rm.coe.int/ CoERMPublicCommonSearchServices/D isplayDCTMContent?documentId=09 000016802e79e6. UNODC Cybercrime Study, supra § 1 C, note 7 (“Based on the core concept of processing computer data or information, it is likely that provisions typically apply to devices such as mainframe and computer servers, desktop personal computers, laptop computers, smartphones, tablet devices, and on-board computers in transport and machinery, as well as multimedia devices such as printers, MP3 players, digital cameras, and gaming machines.”). 16. Kristin Finklea & Catherine A. Theohary, “Cybercrime: Conceptual Issues for Congress and Law Enforcement,” US Congressional Research Service (CRS), (15 Jan. 2015), p. 3, at https://fas.org/sgp/crs/ misc/R42547.pdf. 17. See supra § 1 C. See, e.g., Wall, “Policing Cybercrimes,” supra § 1 B, note 33. Page 138 | Chapter 2 | End Notes Table of Contents

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents