I. Adapting Search & Seizure to the Digital World
In cybercrime, just as in traditional crimes, crucial incriminating evidence is often found during
search and seizure operations. Existing search and seizure procedures can be (A) adapted
to cybercrime searches and seizures, but must also be (B) limited according to the principles
of relevance and effectiveness, which (C) states have done in varying ways. However, while
technological developments have made more work for investigators, (D) advanced forensic tools
can be used as means of identifying relevant e-evidence.
A. The Challenges of Adapting Existing Procedures
“The devil”, it is said, “is in the detail”. While reaching consensus on issues of substantive law is a
complicated matter, difficulties multiply when discussions turn to procedural law: while the purpose
of substantive law is to define the extent of rights and duties, the purpose of procedural law is to
regulate the proceedings providing access to those substantive rights and responsibilities. Thus,
although there may be agreement on the underlying right, defining how that right is accessed,
and what precludes it, requires a greater degree of accord.2 Moreover, the ever-evolving nature of
cybercrime requires that procedural law, just as with substantive law, keep pace with new abuses
and new technologies.3
The challenge is setting regulation that permits rapid transactions around the world but which
relies upon local legal and investigative instruments. Moreover, the swift pace of technological
development and the difficulties this poses for designing, updating and disseminating effective
technical security measures complicate procedural matters in a way that is not necessarily
problematic for substantive law. As discussed further on, arrangements at the international level
might overcome many of these procedural barriers where a formal consensus or an informal
working arraignment can be found (see sections 3 A and 3 B, below). In the short-to-medium term,
cybercrime countermeasures will need to build upon, or at least take into account, existing national
and regional efforts to combat cybercrime and terrorism.4
B. Delimiting Searching & Seizing e-Evidence
Search and seizure procedures play a critical role in securing evidence necessary to proving
culpability. An active mode of investigation, search and seizure involves discovering evidence,
identifying suspects, apprehending offenders and interviewing witnesses. Investigating cybercrime
requires different techniques, not only because of the cross-jurisdictional nature of cybercrime (see
section 1 B, above),5 but also due to the very nature of cyberspace and of e-evidence (see section 2
D, below).6
Page 96 | Chapter 2 | § C. Procedural Issues
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents