B. Korea’s Treatment of the Hearsay Rule The admissibility and authenticity of the electromagnetic record that forms e-evidence may be questioned if its printed form is submitted as evidence into courts. In some countries that do not have written regulations on these matters (e.g., Korea), their highest courts may render decisions or judicial interpretations to address these issues. Such issues include the applicability of hearsay rule to determine authenticity and admissibility of such evidence.64 Case 2.12: Yeong Nam Committee Case (Korea)65 The Supreme Court of Korea has decided that the general hearsay rule, outlined in the Korean Criminal Procedural Law, does in fact apply to the authenticity and admissibility of e-evidence.66 Applied to e-evidence, the rule was used to preclude the introduction as evidence of printed forms of digital files (e.g., electronic documents; emails) saved in computers, servers or other storage devices. Although underscoring that a digitized document “is only different in terms of such document’s recording media” and not “in substance […] significantly different” from a printed document containing the statements, the Court nonetheless excluded the presentation of the printed material out of concern for “the possibility of manipulation during the storage and printing process”. As such, and with “no guarantee for cross-examination”, the Court ruled that “the hearsay rule applies to authenticity of the content of a document recorded in digital files”, and that, “under Article 313 (1) of the Criminal Procedure Act, it is admissible as evidence only when the writers (or ‘the drafters’) or the declarants (or ‘the staters’) statement authenticates it”.67 As with evidence in general, the Court appears to be concerned with assuring the evidentiary chain of custody—that is, its authenticity, integrity and reliability—and, therefore, with demonstrating a proper showing of the printed page as an authentic representation of the original, e-evidence. C. Exceptions to the Hearsay Rule As with any rule, there are exceptions to the applicability of hearsay rules. Such examples might be implemented through various routes. Korea, which has been used as an example already, has introduced exemptions through both legislative and judicial mechanisms.68 In Korea, the legislative exception is rather limited and constrained; by contrast, the judicial exceptions have been more expansive. In the aforecited Korean Supreme Court’s decision, a printed version of the digital file was deemed admissible only if its authenticity were established by the testimony of its asserter at a preparatory hearing to during a trial.69 Page 118 | Chapter 2 | § D. Evidentiary Issues Table of Contents

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents