States.12 A great deal of great value has already been written about the Budapest Convention;
through a few observations are warranted, the Toolkit does not attempt to either repeat or
summarize those commentaries.
The Budapest Convention combines a comprehensive set of rules on different aspects of
cybercrime including substantive, procedural, jurisdictional and international cooperation issues.13
The Convention is legally binding on its Member States. Its clear definition of criminal offenses as
balanced against procedural safeguards14 is an excellent example of good practice. In addition, it
contains important provisions requiring Contracting Parties to observe due process and human
rights while combatting cybercrime.15 While accession is not limited by geography, accession
of non-CoE Member States is restricted to those “invited” upon the unanimous consent of the
Contracting Parties to the Convention16; understandably, eighty-four percent of the Convention’s
signatories are CoE Member States.17 Saying that, the Convention was developed with the
participation of four states that are not CoE Member States,18 and another seventeen non-Member
States have either acceded to the Convention or have been invited to do so.19
B. Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement
The CIS Agreement of 200120 seeks to encourage cooperation in assuring the effective prevention,
detection, suppression, uncovering and investigation of cybercrime offences. To do so, Parties
agree to adopt such organizational and legislative measures as may be necessary to implement
the provisions of this Agreement, and to strive to ensure the harmonization of their national
legislation concerning the combating of offences relating to computer information. While, as with
the Budapest Convention21 and the SCO Agreement (discussed below),22 accession is not limited
by geography, accession is contingent upon the agreement of all Parties.23 Unlike the Budapest
Convention, however, the CIS Agreement was developed by all of its twelve Member States24; thus,
it is unsurprising that only CIS Member States have acceded. However, while all twelve CIS Member
States signed, only six have ratified,25 with one other state (Russia) having sent notification in 2004
that internal procedures for ratification are underway.26
C. Shanghai Cooperation Organization Agreement
With the SCO Agreement of 2009,27 the heads of government of the six SCO Member States
reaffirmed that current science and technology conditions warranted cooperation in order to
enhance the capability of SCO Member States to confront global challenges and threats.28 Like the
Budapest Convention29 and the CIS Agreement,30 accession to the SCO Agreement is not limited
by geography.31 All six SCO Members States have signed the Agreement.32
Page 197 | Chapter 5 | § A. Multilateral Instruments & Cross-border Cooperation
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents