Case 2.7: United States v. Ulbricht (“Silk Road”) (USA)111
Defendant, Ross Ulbricht, was convicted and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility
of parole for conspiracy and money laundering charges stemming from his supposed role
as “Dread Pirate Roberts”, the operator of the online marketplace “Silk Road”. Through
anonymous payments in bitcoin, the Silk Road enabled the sale of, among other things,
controlled substances, pirated software, and fake IDs.112 Run through the Tor network, Silk
Road operated on the Dark Web, a virtual space inaccessible without specialized software or
access authorization.113
Bitcoin is a digital currency manifestation of “blockchain” technology, a method of recording
data that allows for independent recording and verification of “blocks” of digital records
that have been lumped together, and then cryptographically (through a technique known as
“hashing”) and chronologically bound in a “chain” using complex mathematical algorithms.
The recording system can be generically described as a distributed database or “public
ledger”; however, this ledger, to which everyone in the network has access, is not stored
in any one place but rather distributed across multiple computers around the world. The
only recorded data is the fact a transaction’s occurrence and associated hash.114 Not all
blockchains are anonymous, and bitcoin is but one manifestation of blockchain technology.115
Blockchain technology has been described as the most disruptive technology since the
internet.116
Bitcoin transactions, because they are highly secure and highly anonymous, pose certain
challenges to “traditional” forms of combatting financial crimes, particularly with regard to
the finding and extraditing of perpetrators. However, even with bitcoin, anonymity is not
complete: first, as perpetrators must “cash out” of bitcoin to realize their profits, and, second,
as bitcoin’s shared ledger makes transactions public, even if unidentified.
Bitcoin also raises regulatory concerns. While banking is a regulated sector, bitcoin
transactions are not considered part of the banking system in many jurisdictions, often
making it unclear whether banking law or cybercrime law should apply. In banking, various
suspicious activity reporting (SAR) rules require financial institutions to report suspicious
transactions, many, if not all, of which may not apply to bitcoin transactions.117 That said,
the inherent forensic element of bitcoin often lends itself to facilitating investigations once
matters reach that stage.
VIII. Misuse of Devices
The offense of misuse of devices prohibits the use of a device, password or access code in the
furtherance of the afore-enumerated acts.118 Acts criminalizing such offenses have existed for some
time and have typically been used as a means of targeted hacking by targeting the tools enabling
Page 92 | Chapter 2 | § B. Criminalized Conduct
Table of Contents
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents