A/76/136
As the government has indicated on multiple occasions and consistently argues,
148
international law isapplicable in cyberspace. This is also recognised internationally.
Nevertheless, there are still many unanswered questions concerning the precise
manner in which international law should be applied in cyberspace. This is due to the
unique characteristics of the digital world in comparison with the physical world.
Digital data generally moves rapidly and is therefore often difficult to localise. It can
be transferred to another country in a matter of seconds, and can be stored across a
range of different countries. What is more, undesirable activity in cyberspace does
not necessarily always have an immediate physical impact, even though its effects
may nonetheless be serious. It is not yet entirely clear how these and other unique
characteristics should be dealt with in the application of international law. The
government is encouraging international debate on ways to clarify the application of
international law in cyberspace. Clarity and consensus on these points are essential to
the international legal order.
The formulation of responses to these questions is an ongoing process, in which
the government coordinates closely with like-minded partners and pursues initiatives
aimed at furthering dialogue, such as the international consultations on international
law in cyberspace hosted by the Netherlands in The Hague in late May 2019.
In this appendix the government will discuss a number of significant rules of
international law that apply to states in cyberspace. It also explains its interpretation
of the application of those rules. Where relevant, it indicates what issues are still the
subject of international debate and need to be elaborated further. The following topics
will be considered in turn: the obligations of states in cyberspace, the attribution of
cyber operations, and options for responding to undesirable cyber activity by another
state. The government has taken the primary sources of international law defined in
article 38 of the Statute of the International Court of Justice as a starting point. This
article refers, inter alia, to international conventions, international custom and the
general principles of law as sources of international law.
Obligations of states
Respect for sovereignty
The principle of sovereignty, i.e. that states are equal and independent and hold the
highest authoritywithin their own borders, is one of the fundamental principles of
international law. 149 More specific rules of international law, such as the prohibition of
the use of force, the principle of non-interventionand the right of self-defence stem
from this principle. These rules will be discussed in more detail below.
According to some countries and legal scholars, the sovereignty principle does
not constitute an independently binding rule of international law that is separate from
the other rules derived from it.The Netherlands does not share this view. It believes
that respect for the sovereignty of other countries is an obligation in its own right, the
violation of which may in turn constitute an internationally wrongful act. This view is
supported, for example, by the case law of the International Court of Justice, which
ruled in Nicaragua v. United States of America that the United States had acted in
breach of its obligation under customary international law not to violate the
__________________
148
149
21-09670
See, for example, the 2013 and 2015 reports of the Group of Governmental Experts on
Developments in the Field of Information and Telecommunications in the Context of
International Security: https://www.un.org/disarmament/ict-security/; EU Cybersecurity Strategy,
2017; NATO Summit Declarations of 2014, 2016 and 2018.
Island of Palmas arbitral award of 1928: ‘Sovereignty in the relations between States signifies
independence. Independence in regard to a portion of the globe is the right to exercise therein, to
the exclusion of any other State, the functions of a State.’
55/142
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents