A/76/136
Non-Intervention
In connection with this principle, the principle of prohibition of the intervention
in the internal affairs of another State should be addressed (situations of tampering
with the electoral processes in other States are relevant as a discussion under this
principle).
According to international law, States are under the duty not to intervene in
matters within the domestic jurisdiction of any State, in accordance with the Charter;
this means that no State has the right to intervene, directly or indirectly, for any reason
whatever, in the internal or external affairs of any other State.
In order for such intervention to be illegal under international law, it must be
coerced, meaning that the goal of the intervention must be to effectively change the
behavior of the target State; the incidence of coercion must be assessed on a case-bycase basis, in order to determine the violation of the principle of non-intervention.
In other words, the following criteria must be met in order for an act to qualify
as prohibited intervention under international law:
the act must bear on those matters in which States may decide freely (internal
and external affairs – the domain reservé of States);
the act must be coercive in nature;
there has to be a causal nexus between the coercive act and the effect on the
internal or external affairs of the target State.
Therefore, depending on the situation, interference in the internal or external
affairs of Romania (that is interference which causes or may cause harm to Romania’s
economic, political, social and/ or cultural system) may constitute a violation of the
principle of non-intervention.
Prohibition of the threat or use of force
The prohibition of the threat or use of force is a well-established principle of
international law, being included in art. 2(4) of the UN Charter. There are only three
(well determined) exceptions to this prohibition: self-defense in the event of armed
aggression, UNSC Chapter VII authorization of the use of force and consent of the
State on whose territory the operation takes place.
In order to ascertain whether a cyber operation represents a threat or use of force
and whether it even amounts to a cyberattack, a case-by-case analysis must be carried
out to determine the circumstance in which the attack occurred, the nature of the
operation (military or not) and the scale and the effects of the operation (by
comparison against the scale and severity of a conventional (non-cyber) act of
violence covered by the prohibition).
The elements of such an analysis, from the “scale and effects” perspective, are
well established in the ICJ’s relevant jurisprudence.
It is also worth noting that not all cyber operations reach the threshold of use of
force and even less operations reach the threshold of an armed attack; nevertheless
such operations could still be in violation of international law (being a prohibited
intervention or an otherwise violation of the principle of sovereignty).
International humanitarian law
International Humanitarian Law (IHL) applies in the context of cyber operations
carried out as part of an armed conflict (whether international or non-international).
21-09670
77/142
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents