A/76/136
services, or need to search networks or (covertly) gain remote entry to an automated
system. The act of exercising investigative powers in a cross-border context is
traditionally deemed a violation of a country’s sovereignty unless the country in
question has explicitly granted permission (by means of a treaty or other instrument).
Opinion is divided as to what qualifies as exercising investigative powers in a crossborder context and when it is permissible without a legal basis founded in a treaty. In
cyberspace too, countries’ practices differ in their practical approaches to the
principle of sovereignty in relation to criminal investigations. The Netherlands
actively participates in international consultations on the scope for making
investigations more effective, paying specific attention to ensuring the right
safeguards are in place.
In general the government endorses Rule 4, proposed by the drafters of the
151
Tallinn Manual 2.0, on establishing the boundaries of sovereignty in cyberspace.
Under this rule, a violation of sovereignty is deemed to occur if there is 1) infringement
upon the target State’s territorial integrity; and 2) there has been an interference with
or usurpation of inherently governmental functions of another state. The precise
interpretation of these factors is a matter of debate.
Non-intervention principle
The development of advanced digital technologies has given states more
opportunities to exert influence outside their own borders and to interfere in the affairs
of other states. Attempts to influence election outcomes via social media are an
example of this phenomenon. International lawsets boundaries on this kind of activity
by means of the non-intervention principle, which is derived from the principle of
sovereignty. The non-intervention principle, like the sovereignty principle fromwhich
it stems, applies only between states.
Intervention is defined as interference in the internal or external affairs of another
state with a view to employing coercion against that state. Such affairs concern
matters over which, in accordance with the principle of sovereignty, states themselves
have exclusive authority. National elections are an example of internal affairs. The
recognition of states and membership of international organisations are examples of
external affairs.
The precise definition of coercion, and thus of unauthorised intervention, has not
yet fully crystallisedin international law. In essence it means compelling a state to take
a course of action (whether an act or an omission) that it would not otherwise
voluntarily pursue. The goal of the intervention must be to effect change in the
behaviour of the target state. Although there is no clear definition of the element of
coercion, it should be noted that the use of force will always meet the definition of
coercion. Use of force against another state is always a form of intervention.
Prohibition of the use of force
Article 2(4) of the UN Charter lays down a prohibition on the threat or use of
force. It reads as follows: ‘All Members shall refrain in their international relations
from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence
of any state.’ This prohibition applies to the use of force in any form, regardless of the
weapons or means employed. 152
__________________
151
152
21-09670
The Tallinn Manual 2.0 on the International Law Applicable to Cyber Operations was drafted by
a team of experts on international law in consultation with governmental legal practitioners.
Legality of the Threat or Use of Nuclear Weapons, Advisory Opinion, International Court of
Justice (ICJ), 8 July 1996, para. 39.
57/142
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents