A/AC.290/2021/INF/2
United States of America
United States explanation of position at the conclusion of the UN Open Ended
Working Group, delivered by U.S. Head of Delegation Michele Markoff
March 12, 2021
As Prepared
First, I wish to thank Ambassador Lauber, Under Secretary General Nakamitsu, the
Secretariat, and the support team for their tremendous efforts over the last two years
of this Open Ended Working Group (OEWG). The United States is pleased to join
consensus on the final report of the OEWG.
Although the United States voted against General Assembly Resolution 73/ 27 that
established the OEWG, we participated in this OEWG because we welcome
opportunities for international dialogue with other member states on matters of
international security in cyberspace. Building on the work of previous Groups of
Governmental Experts (GGE), and working in parallel with the current GGE, we
have engaged in good faith and with a sense of urgency to universalize the emerging
framework of responsible state behavior in cyberspace that was articulated in the
three consensus GGE reports of 2010, 2013, and 2015 and affirmed by the UN
General Assembly in 2015.
This final report is not perfect in our opinion. And we continue to have reservations
about the need for the new OEWG to run until 2025. However, we recognize that
we are not alone in our disappointment; many states have said they wanted to see
more issues important to them addressed in the report. We therefore support the
initiative to share a two-part chair’s summary on the extent of our discussion and
the many proposals from member states.
As we have indicated throughout our negotiations, the United States cannot
subscribe to calls for new legal obligations. If some states refuse to explicitly
affirm essential elements of existing international law and are unwilling to comply
with the affirmed voluntary norms, what possible confidence could we gain from
negotiating a new treaty instrument? We remain of the view that ICTs are simply
not susceptible to traditional arms control arrangements. It would be futile – and a
tremendous distraction – to spend a decade or more negotiating a new legally
binding instrument.
In the end, however, we think the report is a step forward, and we are pleased to join
consensus on it. All UN member states are making a clear affirmation that
international law applies in cyberspace, and that states should be further guided by a
set of non-binding, voluntary norms of responsible state behavior in cyberspace.
Furthermore, all UN member states recognize the important role of capacity building and confidence-building measures to improve international cyber stability.
Above all, we have been heartened by the level of engagement from member states,
the quality of participants’ contributions and, ultimately, the hard work we all did to
reach a consensus outcome. Our hope is this report’s adoption will usher in a return
to consensus-based action and collaboration toward mutually-beneficial outcomes
21-04015
85/91
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents