A/AC.290/2021/INF/2 • the importance of continuing to deepen our understanding of how international law applies in cyberspace; and • that we cannot immediately solve all the issues at hand in this report, but that we will seek to do so collectively in the future. As with any consensus text there are things we are not as happy with, several things requiring clarification, and indeed a number of things that we are sorry aren’t reflected in the report. These include: • We would have preferred that the order of the ‘norms of behaviour’ and the ‘international law’ sections be reversed. Voluntary, non-binding norms, whilst important, do not replace or alter States’ binding obligations under international law. These legal obligations are the foundation on which everything else i s built, and in our view should therefore also be the foundation of this report. • In paragraph 17 we read the reference to “obligations” as not applying to every element of the framework listed in the paragraph, but rather only to the obligations imposed by international law, as norms of behaviour are voluntary. • We are disappointed to see that paragraph 35 no longer specifically articulates the principles of international law that apply online. We thought this was very useful, and reaffirmed paragraph 28 of the 2015 UNGGE report. For New Zealand it is particularly important to reaffirm: that customary international law on State responsibility already provides a clear existing framework for the legal attribution of malicious State activity; that international law principles regulating the use of force, self-defence, prohibited interventions, and sovereignty apply in cyberspace; and that international humanitarian law applies online, as does international human rights law. • With regard to paragraph 80, it is worth underscoring that the reference to “the possibility of additional legally binding obligations” does not reflect consensus, and indeed many States including New Zealand have consistently underscored that this is neither necessary, nor would it be helpful. As we have said repeatedly, it is a better use of time and delivers more meaningful outcomes to focus on consolidating the progress we have already made, and on supporting states in understanding how international law applies online and to implement the norms we have all agreed. Despite these issues, we are, in the spirit of compromise, prepared to join consensus on the report. We look forward to continuing these important discussions – and tackling some of the issues in more detail – within the UN, and in other fora. As others have said this is not the end, but rather a beginning of something new. But to move to our next phase we must adopt the report today. We encourage all delegations to approach this final report with a spirit of consensus. As we say in New Zealand, Nāku te rourou nāu te rourou ka ora ai te iwi (with your basket and my basket the people will thrive). Thank you 60/91 21-04015

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents