A/AC.290/2021/INF/2
I am pleased to say that we are ready to support your text. That said, please allow us
to point out three elements of particular interest - and concern - to my country in the
second draft.
First, we noticed the new draft did not take on board Brazil’s proposal to include on
paragraph 36 a reference to the 2015 GGE Report as a baseline for further
discussions on the applicability of international law in cyberspace. We would like to
recall that paragraph 28 of the GGE Report included a non-exhaustive list of views
on how international law applies to the use of ICTs by States. The report has been
endorsed unanimously by the UN General Assembly, so that list of common
understandings cannot simply be thrown overboard.
Second, we regret that our proposal to bring para 84 of the first draft (on
international humanitarian law) to the section on conclusions and recommendations,
which garnered widespread support, was not transshipped to the second draft. It is
regrettable that a body of law that enjoys nearly universal support and that has
contributed so much to minimize harm to civilians in conflicts around the world,
and whose principles were nominally referred to in the 2015 GGE report, is now
being treated as a stowaway.
Fortunately, these two gaping holes in the section on international law are plugged
by the clear and unequivocal reaffirmations of the acquis of common understandings
we have adopted by consensus thus far, ane in particular the 2015 GGE Report,
elsewhere in the text.
Lastly, we welcome that the second draft has included in paragraph 7 an indirect
mention to the ongoing GGE, by means of a reference to resolution 73/266, which
established it.
Brazil, along with many other delegations, has been consistently striving for
convergence and complementarity between the current OEWG and the GGE, like
two ships sailing together to the same destination. We are however disappointed that
the very existence of the GGE is barely recognized in the draft OEWG report.
There are at least two paragraphs where a reference to the ongoing GGE would be
particularly useful: the first is paragraph 33, on the development of new norms, and
the second is paragraph 36, on the need to deepen common understandings on how
international law applies to State use of ICTs. Both are precisely the main points of
the mandate given by the UN General Assembly to the ongoing GGE.
But, as the country whose expert is chairing the current GGE, we will interpret the
reference on para 7 as a faint but recognizable radio signal indicating that both our
ships are on the right course.
The section on regular institutional dialogue gives an indication of the route ahead,
with the necessary flexibility that will allow all of us to adjust course and avoid any
possible navigational hazards and areas of doldrums that we may encounter.
Above all, we hope that the adoption of this report by consensus, together with the
report of the ongoing GGE, will lead to the return of a unified, universal,
collaborative, constructive and consensus-based dialogue process within the United
Nations.
21-04015
17/91
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents