Switzerland's position paper on the application of international law in cyberspace
1. Applicability of IHL
IHL is applicable once an international or non-international armed conflict de facto exists. It is
applicable in any armed conflict and to all parties to a conflict. IHL addresses the realities of
war without considering the reasons for or the legality of the use of force. It does not deal with
the legality of war, nor does it legitimise the use of force between states. 26 The purpose of IHL
is to regulate the conduct of hostilities and to protect victims of armed conflict, in particular by
restricting the use of certain means and methods of warfare. The ICJ clearly stated that the
established principles and rules of IHL apply to “all forms of warfare and to all kinds of weapons,
those of the past, those of the present and those of the future”. 27
This is applicable to cyberspace in the same way as for traditional and new operational spaces
(outer space, airspace, land, maritime space, electromagnetic space, information space). IHL
is therefore the main body of international law governing cyber operations that have a
connection with an armed conflict. Implementing IHL effectively contributes to ensuring
international security. Existing IHL, particularly its fundamental principles, places important
limits on the execution of cyber operations in armed conflicts.
2.
Fundamental IHL provisions regulating the
conduct of hostilities
2.1. Principle concerning the means and methods of warfare
IHL prohibits or restricts means (weapons) and methods of warfare through general principles
– regulating conduct or prohibiting certain effects – and specific rules addressing particular
means and methods of warfare. As regards weapons, IHL distinguishes between the legality
of a particular type of weapon (weapons law) and the legality of how it is used (law of targeting).
The inherent characteristics of certain weapon categories entail that their use – in some or all
circumstances – is unlawful per se. The admissibility of all other weapons depends on whether
their use is in conformity with IHL.
This is also applicable to cyberspace. In fact, developing or using new means and methods of
warfare must be in compliance with existing international law, particularly IHL. This is true even
if a weapon is not covered by a specific norm and the treaty provisions governing the conduct
of hostilities do not explicitly refer to new technologies. The custo mary rules of IHL apply
equally to all means and methods of warfare, including in cyberspace. Indeed, it is a long
standing principle that the right of parties to an armed conflict to choose methods or means of
warfare is not unlimited.
2.2. Legality of a particular type of weapon
IHL stipulates that any means or method of warfare possessing one or more of the following
characteristics is inherently unlawful if:
(1) it is of a nature to cause superfluous injury or unnecessary suffering;
26
27
Any use of force betw een states is governed by the UN Charter and relevant customary international law
(see above, section 1.4).
Advisory Opinion on the Legality of the Threat or Use of Nuclear Weapons, ICJ Reports 1996, para. 86; "all
forms of w arfare and to all kinds of w eapons, those of the past, those of the present and those of the future."
9/11
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents