A/76/136
Attribution plays an important role in States’ responses to malicious cyber
activities as a matter of international law. It is crucial, however, to distinguish legal
attribution from attribution in the technical and political senses. States and
commentators often express concerns about the challenge of attribution in a technical
sense – that is, the challenge in light of certain characteristics of cyberspace of
obtaining facts, whether through technical indicators or all-source intelligence, that
would inform a State’s policy and legal determinations about a particular cyber
incident. Others have raised issues related to political decisions about attribution –
that is, considerations that might be relevant to a State’s decision to go public and
identify another State as the actor responsible for a particular cyber incident and to
condemn a particular cyber act as unacceptable. As norms emerge to clarify how
international law addresses the issue of attribution, it would be useful, wherever
possible, for law-abiding states to share information regarding both technical
knowhow and state practice.
D. Countermeasures and Retorsions
In certain circumstances, a State injured by cyber activities that are attributable
to another State and that constitute an internationally wrongful act, but do not amount
to an armed attack, may respond with non-forcible countermeasures. 295 Such
countermeasures must be directed only at the State responsible for the wrongful act,
must meet the requirements of necessity and proportionality, must be designed to
induce the State to return to compliance with its international obligations, and, under
the customary international law of State responsibility, must be suspended without
undue delay if the internationally wrongful act has ceased.
Before an injured State can undertake countermeasures in response to a cyberbased internationally wrongful act attributable to a State, it generally must call upon
the responsible State to cease its wrongful conduct, unless urgent countermeasures
are necessary to preserve the injured State’s rights. The sufficiency of this prior
demand on the responsible State should be evaluated on a case-by-case basis in light
of the particular circumstances of the situation at hand and the purpose of the
requirement, which is to give the responsible State notice of the injured State’s claim
and an opportunity to respond. Countermeasures taken in response to cyber activities
attributable to States that constitute internationally wrongful acts may take the form
of cyber-based countermeasures or non-cyber-based countermeasures.
Countermeasures are distinct from acts of retorsion, which are unfriendly acts
that are not inconsistent with any international obligations. Acts of retorsion may
include the imposition of sanctions or the declaration that a diplomat is persona non
grata. A State can always undertake such responsive measures that are not
inconsistent with any of its international obligations in order to influence the behavior
of other States, including in response to destabilizing cyber activities.
__________________
295
142/142
Countermeasures are acts that would otherwise be contrary to the international obligations of an
injured State vis-à-vis the responsible State if they were not taken in response to an
internationally wrongful act by the latter in order to procure cessation.
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents