Part 2
Chapter
1
Japan’s Security and Defense Policy
Basic Concepts of Japan’s Security and Defense
happiness is fundamentally overturned due to an armed
attack by a foreign country, and for safeguarding these rights
of the people. Hence, “use of force” to the minimum extent
necessary to that end is permitted. This is the basis, or the
so-called basic logic, of the view consistently expressed
by the government to date with regard to “use of force”
exceptionally permitted under Article 9 of the Constitution,
and clearly shown in the document “Relationship between
the Right of Collective Self-Defense and the Constitution”
submitted by the Government to the Committee on Audit of
the House of Councillors on October 14, 1972.
This basic logic must be maintained under Article 9 of the
Constitution.
To date, the Government has considered that “use of
force” under this basic logic is permitted only when an
“armed attack” against Japan occurs. However, in light of
the situation in which the security environment surrounding
Japan has been fundamentally transformed and continuously
evolving by shifts in the global power balance, the rapid
progress of technological innovation, and threats such as
weapons of mass destruction, etc., in the future, even an
armed attack occurring against a foreign country could
actually threaten Japan’s survival, depending on its purpose,
scale and manner, etc.
Japan, as a matter of course, will make the utmost
diplomatic efforts, should a dispute occur, for its peaceful
settlement and take all necessary responses in accordance
with the existing domestic laws and regulations developed
based upon the constitutional interpretation to date. It is still
required, however, to make all necessary preparations in
order to ensure Japan’s survival and protect its people.
Under such recognition and as a result of careful
examination in light of the current security environment,
it has been concluded that not only when an armed attack
against Japan occurs but also when an armed attack against
a foreign country that is in a close relationship with Japan
occurs and as a result threatens Japan’s survival and poses
a clear danger to fundamentally overturn people’s right to
life, liberty and pursuit of happiness, and when there is no
other appropriate means available to repel the attack and
ensure Japan’s survival and protect its people, use of force
to the minimum extent necessary should be interpreted to be
permitted under the Constitution as measures for self-defense
in accordance with the basic logic of the Government’s view
to date.
As a matter of course, Japan’s “use of force” must be
carried out while observing international law. At the same
time, a legal basis in international law and constitutional
interpretation need to be understood separately. In certain
situations, the aforementioned “use of force” permitted under
201
DEFENSE OF JAPAN 2020
the Constitution is, under international law, based on the
right of collective self-defense. The Government has reached
a conclusion that although this “use of force” includes those
which are triggered by an armed attack occurring against a
foreign country, they are permitted under the Constitution,
only when they are taken as measures for self-defense which
are inevitable for ensuring Japan’s survival and protecting its
people, in other words, for defending Japan.
3 Geographic Boundaries within Which the Right of
Self-Defense May Be Exercised
The use of the minimum necessary force to defend Japan
under the right of self-defense is not necessarily confined to
the geographic boundaries of Japanese territory, territorial
waters, and airspace. However, it is difficult to give a general
definition of the actual extent to which it may be used, as this
would vary with the situation.
Nevertheless, the Government interprets that, as a general
rule, the Constitution does not permit armed troops to be
dispatched to the land, sea, or airspace of other countries with
the aim of using force; such overseas deployment of troops
would exceed the definition of the minimum necessary level
of self-defense.
4 Right of Belligerency
Article 9, Paragraph 2 of the Constitution prescribes that “the
right of belligerency of the state will not be recognized.”
However, the “right of belligerency” does not mean the right
to engage in battle; rather, it is a general term for various
rights that a belligerent nation has under international law,
including the authority to inflict casualties and damage upon
the enemy’s military force and to occupy enemy territory.
On the other hand, Japan may of course use the minimum
level of force necessary to defend itself. For example, if
Japan inflicts casualties and damage upon the enemy’s
military force in exercising its right of self-defense, this is
conceptually distinguished from the exercise of the right of
belligerency, even though those actions do not appear to be
different. Occupation of enemy territory, however, would
exceed the minimum necessary level of self-defense and is
not permissible.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents