A/76/136
In such circumstances, the planning of and carrying on of cyber operations must
be done in conformity with the principles governing the conduct of hostilities, namely
distinction, proportionality, necessity and precaution.
There are ongoing discussions in relation to qualifying data as an object for the
purposes of the application of IHL. We take the preliminary view that cyber
operations against data do trigger the application of IHL. Therefore cyber-attacks can
only be directed against those data that represent military objectives according to IHL
and cannot be directed against those data that represent a civilian object which must
be protected under the principle of distinction.
We are also of the view that the principle of neutrality apply as well to cyber
operations as part of an armed conflict and thus, belligerents must refrain from
harming information and communication infrastructure situated on the territory of a
neutral State or from launching attacks from such infrastructure.
Human rights law
Human rights are protected similarly both in offline as well in online contexts.
International law does not recognise a right to States to derogate from their
international human rights obligations as a defensive-type measure – for instance to
restrict access to internet in all circumstance as a responsive measure to counter some
types of conduct in cyberspace (which generally pertain to criminal law, like:
countering terrorism, violent extremism or fraud).
The circumstances in which limitations to human rights are permitted are well
established in international law and apply the same way in offline and in online
contexts. In most cases, the factors to be weighted include whether the restriction
serves a legitimate purpose, whether it has a legal basis and whether it is necessary
and proportionate to the interest it aims to protect.
Therefore, whatever regulation a State adopts (by virtue of its sovereign right)
it must conform with its international obligations in the field of human rights.
Otherwise it entails its legal responsibility under the relevant international
conventions.
It is our view that the existing human rights instruments provide sufficient scope
for effectively safeguarding the protection of human rights in cyberspace.
State responsibility 211
There is an internationally wrongful act of a State when conduct consisting of
an action or omission is:
attributable to the State under international law; and
constitutes a breach of an international obligation of the State
Therefore, from the perspective of state responsibility under international law,
attribution is one of the components.
In cyber context, attribution (especially from the technical point of view) of the
conduct to a State is difficult to determine given the fact that most of the times the
actions are undertaken via proxies.
Therefore, if the conduct is not evident as being of a State organ, then, in order
to be attributed to a State, it must be proven that it is:
__________________
211
78/142
For reference see ILC’s Articles on State responsibility which in RO’s view largely reflect
customary international law.
21-09670
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents