provider liability and responsibility at regional or international level.90
Within the areas of criminalization, law enforcement procedural powers, and international
cooperation, the instruments also show a range of approaches. Figure 3.8 demonstrates the relative
distribution of the number of articles within five binding international or regional instruments that
address each area. Instruments such as the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention and the
League of Arab States Convention cover all four areas. The Draft African Union Convention is
focussed heavily on criminalization with the inclusion of some procedural powers. The
Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement includes a small number of articles on
international cooperation and criminalization. Out of the four areas, the Shanghai Cooperation
Organization Agreement contains only articles on international cooperation.
The coverage of relevant provisions within instruments also varies significantly. Annex Three
to this Study contains a complete analysis of the coverage of provisions in each of the six key areas,
by instrument. The analysis shows diversity in the range of conduct criminalized by the instruments,
in the breadth of law enforcement procedural powers, and in the approaches to jurisdiction and
international cooperation. Annex Three also demonstrates that – while important differences do
exist – many instruments nonetheless share certain ‘core’ provisions. These include, in particular: the
criminalization of acts against the confidentiality, integrity and availability of computer data or
systems; procedural powers including search, seizure, orders for computer data, real-time collection
of computer data, and preservation of data; and general obligations to cooperate in the investigation
of cybercrime criminal matters. The Table below summarizes some of the key results from the
analysis at Annex Three.
90
Criminalization
• Most instruments contain an extensive list of offences. Others focus only on a
limited thematic offence area, such as instruments focusing on child pornography
and child protection
• Acts against the confidentiality, integrity and availability of computer data or
systems are most commonly criminalized, followed by computer-related fraud or
forgery, and computer-related production, distribution or possession of child
pornography
• In addition to the acts identified in Chapter One of this Study in the section on
'Describing cybercrime', some instruments also criminalize a wide range of acts,
including computer-related offences against public order, morality or security
• Some instruments provide that conventional crimes committed by means of a
computer system should be an aggravating circumstance
Procedural
powers
• Search, seizure, orders for stored computer data and subscriber information, realtime collection of computer data, and expedited preservation of computer data are
the most common procedural powers
• Trans-border access to computer data is envisaged by three instruments
Electronic
evidence
• The few (mainly, non-binding) instruments that address electronic evidence cover
areas including the general admissibility of electronic evidence, the burden of
proving authenticity, the best evidence rule, the presumption of integrity, and
preservation standards
Jurisdiction
• Nearly all instruments include the territorial principle and nationality principle
(where dual criminality exists) as bases for jurisdiction
• Other bases for jurisdiction, not found in all instruments, include acts directed
against a computer system or data located within the territory and a state interests
principle
• Two instruments provide guidance on establishment of the place of a cybercrime
offence
See, for example, EU Directive on e-Commerce, Arts. 12 to 15.
70
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents