and focal points for the provision of 24 hours a day communication channels.98
3.4 Implementing multilateral instruments at the national level
Key results:
In addition to formal membership and implementation, multilateral cybercrime
instruments have influenced national laws indirectly, through use as a model by nonStates parties, or via the influence of legislation of States parties on other countries
Membership of a multilateral cybercrime instrument corresponds with the perception of
increased sufficiency of national criminal and procedural law, indicating that current
multilateral provisions in these areas are generally considered effective
Fragmentation at the international level, and diversity of national laws, in terms of
cybercrime acts criminalized, jurisdictional bases, and mechanisms of cooperation, may
correlate with the existence of multiple cybercrime instruments with different thematic
and geographic scope
The manner in which international or regional instruments are implemented in national law,
as well as the effectiveness of the application and enforcement of new rules, can be decisive factors
in the success, or otherwise, of harmonization.99 States may interpret or implement the provisions of
international instruments in different ways, leading to further divergence across countries. This, in
itself, is not a problem: countries will not always implement international frameworks in exactly the
same way, due to different legal traditions and limitations that exist at the national level.100 At the
same time, however, the goal of
implementation is to provide a certain
Implementation of the EU Decision on Attacks against
Information Systems
degree of compliance of national
legislation
with
international
A report on the implementation of the EU Framework Decision
on Attacks against Information Systems (2005) reveals
frameworks.
Vertical (direct) implementation
‘Direct’ implementation of a
multilateral treaty follows signature and
ratification of, or accession to, a treaty.
For most international rules to become
operative, they must be applied by State
officials or individuals within domestic
legal systems. States may achieve this
either through ‘standing incorporation’
of international rules into domestic law
(often associated with so-called ‘monist’
systems) or by ‘legislative incorporation’
98
99
100
significant divergence in the use of the option not to criminalize
‘minor cases.’ Member states, for example:
Criminalized access only with the intent to perpetrate data
espionage;
Criminalized illegal access only in cases where the data was
subsequently misused or damaged;
Established a condition of endangering the data accessed as a
requirement for criminal responsibility.
The report on implementation pointed out that, in general, ‘such
a divergence of interpretation and application of the option not to criminalize
certain acts poses a serious risk to the objective to approximate Member
State rules on criminal law in the area of attacks against information
systems.’
Source: European Commission. 2008. COM (2008) 448 final.
See Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 35 and League of Arab States Convention, Art. 43.
Miquelon-Weismann, M. F., 2005. The Convention on Cybercrime: A Harmonized Implementation of International Penal Law:
What Prospects for Procedural Due Process? John Marshall Journal of Computer & Information Law, 23(2):329-61.
See Klip, A., Nelken, D., 2002. Changing Legal Cultures. In: Likosky, M. (ed.) Transnational Legal Processes. London: Butterworths;
Graziadei, M., 2009. Legal Transplants and the Frontiers of Legal Knowledge. Theoretical Inquiries in Law, 10(2): 723-743.
72
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents