CHAPTER THREE: LEGISLATION AND FRAMEWORKS
(in
‘dualist’
systems),
whereby
international rules become applicable
within the national legal system only if
and once the relevant national legislation
is passed.101
The incorporation of cybercrime
instrument provisions into national law
will often involve amendment of
legislation such as the criminal code and
criminal procedure code in order either to
introduce new specific offences, or to
amend existing ones.
Implementation of the ECOWAS Draft Directive
In 2008, a country in Western Africa adopted a law concerning
regulations provided at the regional level by ECOWAS on
cybercrime. The specific amendments included:
Creation of IT-specific offences in the fields of criminal
protection of IT systems and electronic data, illegal
content, computer fraud, technical assistance services,
and digital advertising;
Updating of legislation on existing offences to make it
relevant to the new IT/telecommunications environment
(in the fields of criminal protection against theft, physical
damage to property, etc.);
Amendments to the law on criminal procedure to
implement the IT-specific instruments;
Creation of new guidelines on cyber-related cooperation
with regard to ECOWAS states, the Council of Europe,
and
cooperation
between
the
state
and
ECOWAS/Council of Europe/G8 Network.
The result in national law may be
significantly different from State party to
State party. A specific effect that the
Source: Mouhamadou, L.O. 2011. Cybercrime, Civil Liberties, and
implementation of an international
Privacy in the Economic Community of West African States . 21st
instrument has on the national legal
Annual Computers, Freedom and Privacy Conference 2011.
system of one state, for example, may
never occur in another.102 An assessment
of the implementation of the EU Decision on Attacks against Information Systems103 illustrates well
the challenges faced in harmonization of cybercrime legislation – even in the context of a binding
framework and countries accustomed to implementation of supra-national law.104 As illustrated in
the box, assessment of implementation showed significant divergences in national legal provisions
designed to implement the Decision. The assessment also highlights a further point – that review of
implementation of any instrument is a technical and challenging process, requiring time, resources
and full information on both legislative provisions, and their application in practice.105 It is beyond
the scope and mandate of this Study to carry out any form of assessment of implementation of the
different international and regional cybercrime instruments referred to in this Chapter.
Nonetheless, analysis of responses to the Study questionnaire alone shows that membership
of a multilateral instrument correlates with a perception of increased sufficiency of national cybercrime
criminal and procedural law. Figure 3.9 demonstrates that responding countries that were not party
to a multilateral cybercrime instrument more frequently reported that national cybercrime
criminalization and procedural laws were ‘not sufficient.’106
101
102
103
104
105
106
Cassese, A., 2005. International Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press, p.220-221.
Klip, A., 2006. European Integration and Harmonisation and Criminal Law. In: Curtin, D.M. et al. European integration and law:
four contributions on the interplay between European integration and European and national law to celebrate the 25th anniversary
of Maastricht University’s Faculty of Law. For general discussion, see Legrand, P., 1997. The Impossibility of ‘Legal Transplants,
Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law, (4):111-124.
European Commission. 2008. Report from the Commission to the Council based on Article 12 of the Council Framework Decision of 24 February
2005 on attacks against information systems. COM (2008) 448 final, Brussels, 14 July 2008. It should be noted that the implementation
analysis was carried out only for 20 out of 27 Member States of the European Union, and was based only on formal analysis of the
information submitted by Member States.
Calderoni, F., 2010. The European legal framework on cybercrime: striving for an effective implementation. Crime, Law and Social
Change, 54(5):339-357.
The Mechanism for the Review of Implementation of the United Nations Convention against Corruption, for example, involves a
detailed terms of reference for the review process, as well as guidelines for governmental experts and the secretariat in the conduct
of country reviews. See http://www.unodc.org/documents/treaties/UNCAC/Publications/ReviewMechanismBasicDocuments/Mechanism_for_the_Review_of_Implementation_-_Basic_Documents_-_E.pdf
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q19. Figure 3.9 is calculated for the following signed or ratified instruments: Council of Europe
Cybercrime Convention, League of Arab States Convention, Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement, and Shanghai
Cooperation Organization Agreement.
73
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents