Not party to a multilateral instrument Figure 3.9: Impact of multilateral instruments on perceived sufficiency of legislation Party to a multilateral instrument While a relationship between ‘sufficiency’ of legislation and ‘instrument membership’ can be demonstrated, responses to the study did not reveal a clear pattern between ‘perceived harmonization’ and ‘instrument membership.’ As noted above, while countries in Europe, for example, perceive high levels of harmonization ‘with multilateral instruments,’ this does not always translate into perceived high levels of harmonization of national legislation within the region.107 Procedural Powers Not sufficient Partly sufficient Criminalization Sufficient Procedural powers Criminalization 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q19. (n=42) Similarly, calculations based on the two respondent groups above (‘instrument’ and ‘no instrument’) do not reveal significant differences in perceived levels of harmonization with other countries, or within respective regions.108 Nonetheless, multilateral instruments are usually inherently intended to play a role in harmonization and it is possible that responses to the questionnaire also reflect differences in perceptions as to what constitutes ‘harmonization’ in the first place. In this respect, a number of countries reported positive experiences of implementation of multilateral instruments. In reporting on harmonization successes, for example, many responding countries noted a positive experience in incorporating provisions from instruments such as the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention into national law.109 Indirect influence In addition to formal instrument membership and implementation, multilateral cybercrime instruments have also influenced national laws indirectly. This includes through use as a model by non-States parties, or via the influence of legislation of States parties on other countries. Countries may use more than one instrument to draft national legislation and a number of countries reported that this was the case.110 One country in Western Africa, for example, noted use of the Commonwealth Model Law, the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, and the ECOWAS Draft Directive. Another country in Western Asia reported use of both the League of Arab States Model Law, and national legislative provisions from other countries in the region.111 In addition, as noted previously, multilateral instruments themselves include a significant amount of cross-fertilization between the texts. The Commonwealth Model Law and the EU Decision on Attacks against Information Systems, for example, were drafted closely in line with the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention. 107 108 109 110 111 See above, Section 3.2 Divergence and harmonization of laws, Harmonization of laws. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q17. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q16. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q12 and Q14. Ibid. 74

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents