CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION a computer system or data, and illegal data interference or system damage. The distribution between cyber-specific offences and general offences is examined in detail for selected acts later in this Chapter. The wide distribution between cyber-specific and general offences supports the approach taken at the international level to characterize the place of ‘cybercrime’ within the spectrum of ‘crime’ as a whole. Initial work undertaken on an ‘International Crime Classification Framework’ mandated by the United Nations Economic and Social Council,3 for example, classifies some cybercrime acts at the ‘vertical’ level (as specific, mutually-exclusive offence categories), but also envisages cybercrime acts at the ‘horizontal’ level, as an ‘attribute’ of traditional crimes that involve a computer element.4 In addition to examining the cyber-specific or general nature of cybercrime offences, it is also important to consider the general criminal law. Cybercrime offences in national laws are not applied or interpreted by the criminal justice system in isolation, but rather with reference to rules that apply to all offences, such as rules on complicity, attempt, omission, state of mind, and legal defences. When it comes to ‘state of mind’, in particular, any comparative law exercise must be carried out with caution. Different legal systems use a range of different concepts and definitions. The same terms in different legal systems may even have different meanings. Legal systems may distinguish between ‘will’ and ‘knowledge’, or define a range of mental states, such as ‘purposefully’, ‘with knowledge’, ‘recklessly’, and ‘negligently’.5 In all legal systems, however, two general poles of ‘intentional’ and ‘non-intentional’ culpable conduct can be discerned.6 Such distinctions are important when it comes to cybercrime offences. A number of international and regional instruments, for example, specify that conduct shall be established as a criminal offence ‘when committed intentionally.’7 Other instruments allow that criminal offences may be committed recklessly. The Draft African Union Convention, for example, states that each Member state of the African Union shall take the necessary legislative measures to set up ‘as a penal offence’ the fact ‘even out of negligence’ of processing of personal data, without following the necessary rules for data processing.8 In some African countries, the mental element of ‘fraudulently’ is also commonly used in penal law. The ECOWAS Draft Directive, for example, contains articles such as the ‘fraudulent interception of computer data’ and ‘fraudulent access to computer systems.’9 In this context, the level of intent required might be considered equivalent to a form of ‘dishonest’ intent – more than the general standard of ‘intentionally’, but less than a specific intent to obtain monies, goods or services, by deceit or falsehood. Due to the potential broad reach of some cybercrime offences, such as illegal access to computer data, it is important that the mental element of cybercrime acts is clearly defined in law. This may be in the offence itself, or through the general criminal law. Where possible, the legislative analysis in this Chapter attempts to identify similarities and differences in offence intent elements. 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 United Nations Economic and Social Council, 2012. Resolution 2012/18. Improving the quality and availability of statistics on crime and criminal justice for policy development. See Centre of Excellence in Statistical Information on Government, Crime, Victimization and Justice, 2012. Report on the Consultation meeting for the International Crime Classification Framework. 17-19 October 2012, Mexico City. For the categories of the mental element in European continental law countries, see, for example, Roxin, C., 2010. Strafrecht AT I. 4th ed. Munich. pp.436 et seq. and 1062 et seq. (Germany); Picotti, L., 1993. Il dolo specific. Milan (Italy). For the categories of the mental element in common law countries, see Dressler, J., 2012. Understanding Criminal Law. 6th ed. pp.117–144 (United States); Ashworth, A., 2009. Principles of Criminal Law. 6th ed. pp.75, 154-156, 170-191 (United Kingdom). ‘Intentionally’ includes especially purposely and knowingly. ‘Non-intentionally’ ranges from recklessness to gross and simple negligence. See, for example, Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Arts. 2-9. Draft African Union Convention, Part IV, Section 3, Art III-29. ECOWAS Draft Directive, Arts. 2-11. 79

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents