Figure 4.5 shows that, of those countries that criminalize illegal access, around 70 per cent criminalize mere illegal access. The remaining 30 per cent require additional conditions for the act to constitute a crime. There is no clear regional pattern to this result. A few countries require either ‘infringement of security measures’ or additional Figure 4.5: Criminalization of mere illegal access intent, such as the ‘intent to commit another crime.’ Some national laws limit illegal access Yes only to cases of ‘grave violations’ or ‘serious No crimes,’ as in the case of one country in 31% Oceania.26 In addition, some national statutes criminalize illegal access only where data are 69% ‘copied’, ‘blocked’, ‘stolen’, ‘modified’ or ‘deleted’, or if illegal access is committed ‘in connection with’ system interference. In some countries, this leads to the criminalization of illegal access as one of the elements of data and system interference offences. For example, one Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=90) country in Eastern Europe criminalizes the act of ‘interference with data and systems’ only if committed ‘in conjunction’ with unauthorized access to a computer system. This has the effect of limiting criminalization of data interference to the cases where illegal access is the first step in committing the offence against data and systems. State of mind - All multilateral instruments require the crime of illegal access to be committed intentionally or, in the case of two instruments, ‘fraudulently.’27 However, the definition of what constitutes ‘intent’ is usually left to the implementing country. For example, the Explanatory Report to the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention states explicitly that the exact meaning of ‘intentionally’ should be ‘left to national interpretation.’28 In this respect, as discussed above, the exact state of mind considered to constitute ‘intentionality’ differs between many national legal systems – depending upon both special and general criminal law.29 Analysis of primary source legislation, however, shows that, for those illegal access provisions that specifically mention state of mind, the mental elements of ‘intentionally’, ‘knowingly’, ‘wilfully’, and ‘fraudulently’ are used – indicating that some form of intentionality is most usually required for the offence. In only two countries included in the analysis, situated in the Caribbean and Oceania, can illegal access be committed ‘recklessly.’ Aggravating circumstances – Four multilateral cybercrime instruments include aggravating circumstances in provisions on illegal access. The League of Arab States Model Law provides for aggravated penalties for illegal access committed ‘with intention of nullifying, deleting, destroying, disclosing, damaging, changing or re-disseminating personal data or information’ (Art. 3), or for illegal access committed by the offender ‘in the course of or because of the discharge of his functions or has facilitated commission of the offences by a third party’ (Art. 5). The League of Arab States Convention provides for aggravating circumstances if access leads to the ‘obliteration, modification, distortion, duplication, removal or destruction of 26 27 28 29 This country limits criminalization to acts committed with the intent to commit, or facilitate the commission of, a serious offence against a law by access. A serious offence is further defined as an offence punishable with lifetime imprisonment or at least for a period of more than five years. Draft African Union Convention, Arts. III-15, III-16; ECOWAS Draft Directive, Arts. 2, 3. Council of Europe, 2001. Explanatory Report to Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, ETS No. 185, para. 39: ‘All the offences contained in the Convention must be committed ‘intentionally’ for criminal liability to apply. In certain cases an additional specific intentional element forms part of the offence. For instance, in Article 8 on computer-related fraud, the intent to procure an economic benefit is a constituent element of the offence. The drafters of the Convention agreed that the exact meaning of ‘intentionally’ should be left to national interpretation.’ See, for example, LaFave, R.W., 2000. Criminal Law. 3rd ed. St. Paul: MN. pp. 224-234; Fletcher, G., 1998. Basic Concepts of Criminal Law. Oxford University Press, pp.99-100, 111-129; Fletcher, G., 1971. The Theory of Criminal Negligence: A Comparative Analysis. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 119(3):401-403. 84

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents