CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION
Arab States Model Law (Art. 8). Some multilateral instruments, in addition to non-public
transmissions, also cover the interception of ‘electromagnetic emissions’ – a term used to widen the scope
of the offence.34
While the vast majority of multilateral
instruments limit the application of illegal
interception to private transmissions of computer
data, analysis of legislation for 78 countries shows
that, on the national level, the scope of the offence
in many cases is not restricted to non-public data
transfers. Figure 4.7 shows that just under 30 per
cent of countries examined limit unauthorized
interception to private or protected transmissions.
In practice, however, due to the broad interpretation
of ‘non-public’, it is likely that this does not
significantly broaden the offence scope.
Figure 4.7: Restriction to private/non‐public
transmissions
Included
28%
Not included
72%
Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=78)
A further issue concerns the concept of ‘transmission’. Data can be considered ‘in
transmission’ when they have not
reached the final destination – either the
Illegal interception: National example from a country in the
system or the intended recipient. Data
Americas
transmission could be considered to end
A person who knowingly and without lawful excuse or
when the computer system of destination
justification intercepts by technical means
(a) any transmission to, from or within a computer system that is
is reached. Alternatively, data could be
not available to the public; or
considered as ‘in transmission’, when
(b) electromagnetic emissions that are carrying computer data
stored in the system until the intended
from a computer system
is guilty of an offence and is liable on conviction on indictment to
recipient obtains access to them. No
a fine of ____ or to imprisonment for a term of ____ years or to
multilateral
instrument
provides
both.
guidance on the end-point of
transmission. The distinction is important with respect to temporary data storage that occurs when
computer data are transmitted with the use of protocols operated on a ‘store-and-forward’ basis.35
Several countries have addressed this issue in national legislation. One country in Oceania,
for example, uses a legal provision which excludes ‘…communication stored on a highly transitory basis as
an integral function of the technology used in its
Figure 4.8: Are technical means included as an element of
transmission’ from the definition of stored
the illegal interception offence?
communication. Thus, such data could be
Included
included within the scope of the offence
Not included
of illegal interception of computer data.
42%
Acts
covered
–
Multilateral
instruments, with one exception,36 limit
acts of interception to those committed
using technical means. As stated in the
explanatory report to the Council of
Europe Cybercrime Convention, this
58%
Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=78)
34
35
36
Including Commonwealth Model Law; ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts; EU Directive Proposal on Attacks against
Information Systems; and Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention.
Walden, I., 2007. Computer Crime and Digital Investigations. Oxford: OUP, p.185.
League of Arab States Convention, Art. 8.
87
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents