covered in one provision, as transmitting
data might have an effect on the system.
However, analysis shows that there is no
correlation. Countries with separate
provisions on data interference also
include transmission in the list of
prohibited acts.
Figure 4.12: Elements constituting illegal data interference
Damaging/deleting
95%
Altering
98%
Suppressing
43%
Inputting
35%
Some multilateral instruments
permit countries to make reservations
Transmitting
12%
regarding the effects caused by data
interference. The Council of Europe
Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=83)
Cybercrime Convention, for example,
provides the possibility to limit criminalization of data interference to cases of serious harm.41 The
EU Decision on Attacks against Information Systems grants the freedom not to criminalize minor
cases.42
Figure 4.13: Is harm included as a necessary element of
data interference?
17%
Included
32%
Not included
Included as an
aggravated
circumstance
51%
Figure 4.13 shows that at the
national level, only 17 per cent of the
countries examined include harm or
loss as a necessary element of data
interference. Just over 30 per cent of
countries provide for aggravating
circumstances with respect to the harm
caused by data interference. Half of
national laws do not refer at all to
damage caused by data interference
in relevant national provisions.
Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=83)
In the same way as computer
data, computer systems can be
damaged in various ways, such as by transmission, alteration or deletion of data, by electromagnetic
interference or by cutting the system off from a power supply. System interference provisions in
multilateral instruments usually include ‘alteration.’ ‘deletion.’ and ‘transmission of data’ or any other
‘manipulation’ of data or programmes. Broader
System interference: National example from a
definitions, however, can be found in the
country in Southern Africa
Commonwealth Model Law and the
ITU/CARICOM/CTU
Model Legislative
Damaging or denying access to computer system
Any person who without lawful authority or lawful
Texts, which include not only the manipulation
excuse, does an act which causes directly or indirectly
of data, but also cutting off the electricity supply
(a) a degradation, failure, interruption or obstruction
of the operation of a computer system; or
to a computer system, causing electromagnetic
(b) a denial of access to, or impairment of any
interference and corrupting a computer system
program or data stored in, the computer system,
by any means.43
shall commit an offence and shall, on conviction be
liable to a fine not exceeding ___ and to penal
servitude not exceeding ___ years.
Figure 4.14 shows that for the majority
of national legislation examined, the acts of
41
42
43
Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 4.
EU Decision on Attacks against Information Systems, Art. 3.
Commonwealth Model Law, Art. 7; ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts, Art. 3(10).
90
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents