CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION
shows that more than 80 per cent of
Figure 4.19: Acts concering computer misuse tools
countries criminalize ��dissemination’.
‘Possession’ of misuse tools is
Possession
64%
criminalized in close to 65 per cent
of countries. Some national laws also
Distribution/Making available
include criminalization of acts that
are not provided for by international
or regional instruments but can be
Codes disclosure
61%
considered as related to computer
misuse tools provisions. Many
Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=70)
countries in the Caribbean region,
for example, criminalize the act of ‘unauthorized disclosure’ of passwords or access codes.
84%
Spam
It is estimated that spam accounted for
around 70 per cent of global internet e-mail traffic in
mid-2012. 56 Spam is an issue of consent rather than
content. It is often defined as the sending of
unsolicited bulk messages. 57 The problems caused by
spam go far beyond the simple annoyance of
internet users. 58 Spam consumes resources such as
bandwidth, server capacity, and network
infrastructure, and represents an entry point for the
spread of malware and phishing of access codes and
financial information. It is thus linked with conduct
such as data and system interference – directly and
indirectly endangering the integrity and availability
of computer data and systems.
Nonetheless, harmonization
of legal approaches towards spam is
far
from
complete. 59
Two
multilateral
(non-binding)
cybercrime instruments propose the
criminalization of spam – the
COMESA Draft Model Bill (Art.
19), and the ITU/CARICOM/CTU
Model Legislative Texts (Art. 15).
None of the binding multilateral
cybercrime instruments include
criminal provisions on spam,
although the preamble to the EU
56
57
58
59
Spam: COMESA Draft Model Bill
Article 19 – Unauthorized Access to
Computer Programs, Computer Data,
Content Data, Traffic Data
...
(g) Spamming
A person who transmits any unsolicited
electronic information to another person for
purposes of illegal trade or commerce or other
illegal activity, shall have committed a criminal
offense punishable by a fine of [amount]_______
and/or imprisonment for a period of
__________ years, or to both.
Figure 4.20: Criminalization of the sending or controlling of the
sending of SPAM
Yes, cyber-specific offence
21%
Yes, general offence
Yes, both
No, not a criminal offence
14%
63%
2%
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q33. (n=51)
Symantec Intelligence Report, June 2012; Kaspersky Lab Report, June 2012.
For a working (rather than legal) definition, see http://www.spamhaus.org/consumer/definition/
Sorkin, D., 2001. Technical and Legal Approaches to Unsolicited Electronic Mail. University of San Francisco Law Review, 35(2):325384
De Hert, P., Fuster, G., Koops, B. J., 2006. Fighting cybercrime in the two Europes. The added value of the EU framework
decision and the Council of Europe Convention. International Review of Penal Law, 77(3-4):503-524.
95
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents