CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION
concern the manipulation of computer data, or
interference with a computer system, that leads
to economic benefit for the offender or another
person.
Computer-related fraud:
Cybercrime Convention
Council
of
Europe
Article 8
Each Party shall adopt such legislative and other
measures as may be necessary to establish as criminal
offences under its domestic law, when committed
intentionally and without right, the causing of a loss of
property to another person by:
a any input, alteration, deletion or suppression of
computer data;
b any interference with the functioning of a
computer system,
with fraudulent or dishonest intent of procuring,
without right, an economic benefit for oneself or for
another person.
Six instruments also contain specific
provisions on forgery.63 Acts covered by
computer-related forgery provisions include the
alteration, deletion, transmission and other
manipulation of computer data, resulting in
inauthentic date that is intended to be acted
upon or used as if it were authentic.
At the national level, however, the
situation varies significantly concerning the
existence of cyber-specific provisions
Figure 4.21: Criminalization of computer‐related fraud or
for fraud and forgery. Responding
forgery
countries to the Study questionnaire
3%
Yes, cyber‐specific offence
indicated that computer-related fraud
15%
Yes, general offence
or forgery was covered by existing
41%
general legislation (over 40 per cent).
Yes, both
Almost the same proportion reported
No, not a criminal offence
the existence of a cyber-specific
offence, while 15 per cent of
countries use both approaches.64
41%
This diversity derives in part
from differences between national
legal systems in the extent to which
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q30. (n=59)
‘traditional’ offences can be applied in
a ‘cyber’ environment. Traditional
fraud offences for example often require the direct deception of a ‘person’ and may suffer challenges
in their extension to acts committed
through the manipulation of a
Computer-related forgery: Draft African Union Convention
computer system or computer data.65
Article III – 8
Similarly, traditional forgery offences
often require alteration of a ‘visual
Each Member State of the African Union shall take the
legislative measures to set up as a penal offense the fact of
representation’, a requirement which may
producing or manufacturing a range of digital data by
not, depending upon the national legal
fraudulently introducing, deleting or suppressing computerized
approach, be satisfied by alteration of
data held, processed or transmitted by a computer system,
resulting in fake data, with the intention that the said data would
intangible data on electronic devices.66
be taken into account or used for illegal purposes as if they were
the original data
63
64
65
66
Draft African Union Convention, Art. III-24; Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 7; COMESA Draft Model Bill, Art.
23; ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts, Art. 11; League of Arab States Model Law, Art. 4; ECOWAS Draft Directive,
Art. 8.
Study cybercrime Questionnaire. Q30.
Sieber, U., 2008. Mastering complexity in the global cyberspace : The harmonization of computer-related criminal law. In : DelmasMarty, M., Pieth, M. and Sieber, U., (eds.) Les chemins de l’Harmonisation Penale/Harmonising Criminal Law. Collection de L’UMR de Droit
Compare de Paris. Vol. 15. Paris: Société de législation comparé.
Ibid.
97
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents