In order to address such
Combining computer-related fraud and forgery: National example
legal challenges, national cyberfrom a country in Southern Africa
specific provisions for fraud
(1) A person who performs any of the acts described under this Part, for
often focus on the manipulation
the purposes of obtaining any unlawful advantage by causing forged data
of computer data or systems
to be produced, with the intent that it be considered or acted upon as if it
were authentic, commits an offence and shall on conviction be liable to a
with dishonest or fraudulent
fine ___ or to imprisonment ____, or to both.
intent, rather than on the
(2) A person who, with intent to procure any advantage for himself or
herself or another person, fraudulently causes loss of property to another
element of deception of an
person byindividual. In some countries,
(a) any input, alteration, deletion or suppression of data; or
computer-related
fraud
(b) any interference with the functioning of a computer or computer
system,
provisions also criminalize the
commits an offence and shall on conviction be liable to a fine ____ or to
unauthorized use of data, in
imprisonment_____, or to both.
addition to the use of false data
(see example box from a country
in Southern Asia). This can lead
to broad application of computer-related fraud provisions, for example, to all cases of computer use
for illicit enrichment.67 A number of countries continue to amend national laws in order to
introduce cyber-specific offences for computer-related fraud. One country in Eastern Europe, for
example, has recently adopted a new article on computer-related fraud in its criminal code after
more than a decade of prosecuting cases of computer fraud under a combination of general fraud
and illegal access provisions. Although it had previously supported this approach, the reform was
initiated by the Supreme Court with a view to ensuring more efficient prosecution of suspects and
removing any remaining legal uncertainty about the applicability of traditional fraud provisions.
Some countries also apply provisions on theft to cases of computer fraud by, considering
computer data to be fall under definitions of ‘goods’ or ‘things.’ This approach is taken by some
countries in Western Europe, Northern Europe, and North America. Several countries further have
provisions on ‘qualified theft’ or larceny which include the use of computer systems for commission of
the offence (see example box from a county in Western Asia).
National provisions on computerrelated forgery typically require two necessary
elements: (i) the alteration or manipulation of
computer data, and (ii) a specific intent to use
the data as if they were authentic. Alternatively,
countries may extend the definition of the
object of traditional forgery. A number of
countries in Europe, for example, have covered
computer-related forgery by extending the
definition of ‘document’ to include computer
data. Other countries apply general provisions
to computer-related forgery without amending
legislation if traditional provisions of forgery
can be interpreted to include digital documents,
signatures and data.
67
Computer-related forgery: National example
from a country in Southern Europe
Article --- Computer Forgery
(1) Whoever, without authorization, develops,
installs, alters, deletes or makes unusable computer
data or programs that are of significance for legal
relations in order for them to be used as authentic,
or whoever uses such data or programs shall be
punished by a fine of by imprisonment not
exceeding _______.
(2) If the criminal offence referred to in paragraph 1
of this Article is committed in connection with the
computer data or programs of a governmental
body, a public institution or a company of special
public interest, or if significant damage is caused,
the perpetrator shall be punished by imprisonment
for ________.
See Sieber, U., 1985. Informationstechnologie und Strafrechtsreform. Cologne: Carl Heymanns Verlag, p.39.
98
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents