CHAPTER FIVE: LAW ENFORCEMENT AND INVESTIGATIONS
searches’, but that the provision only allowed searches for hardware and not of computer data.43. Less
than 20 per cent of responding countries indicated the existence of cyber-specific powers for search
or seizure.
Just under 10 per cent of countries reported that there was no power at all for search and
seizure – at least for computer data. One country from Western Asia, for example, stated that ‘In
relation to accessing equipment and hardware, the Criminal Procedure Code deals with the case of physical access by
members of the judicial police to homes, but does not address electronic crime… These texts do not allow members of
the judicial police to enter electronic networks and email on the grounds of suspicion of commission of an offence.’44
The same country noted that law reform would be required in order to provide such powers and
currently ‘If such entry [were to] take place in the absence of a legal provision, that would violate the provisions of the
Constitution and the law.’
Preservation of computer data
Storing computer data requires resources and money. As a result, computer data is typically
stored only for the amount of time for which it is needed for processing. In the case, for example, of
‘chat’ or VOIP content that passes through a service provider’s service, this might only be for the
amount of time needed for operational purposes, such as the identification of system faults, or
customer billing. This could range from a few seconds, to hours, or a few days, or weeks. In addition
to the pragmatic cost implications of data storage, many countries also have data protection
frameworks that specify that data must not be
retained for periods longer than that required by
Expedited preservation of data: National
the purposes for which the data are processed.45
example from a country in Southern Africa
Due legal process requirements, or – in
Preservation order
transnational cases – international cooperation
(1) Any investigatory authority may apply to the
requests, may easily take a longer time than the
Judge in Chambers for an order for the
lifespan of the data, before the relevant search
expeditious preservation of data that has
been stored or processed by means of a
warrant or order for supply of stored data can be
computer system or any other information
obtained.46
and communication technologies, where
As a result, seven international and regional
cybercrime instruments contain provisions aimed at
establishing mechanisms for preventing the
deletion of computer data important to cybercrime
investigations.47 Such actions may be given effect to
by an order to a person in control of computer data
to preserve and maintain the integrity of the data
for a specified period of time, or by expedited
procedures for otherwise securing the data, such as
through a search and seizure warrant. Key features
of typical ‘expedited’ preservation provisions may
include application of a more limited set of
43
44
45
46
47
(2)
(3)
(a)
(b)
(c)
there are reasonable grounds to believe that
such data is vulnerable to loss or
modification.
For the purposes of subsection (1), data
includes traffic data and subscriber
information.
An order made under subsection (1) shall
remain in force until such time as may reasonably be required
for the investigation of an offence;
where prosecution is instituted, until the final
determination of the case; or
until such time as the Judge in Chambers
deems fit.
Ibid
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q53.
See Chapter Eight (Prevention), Section 8.3 Cybercrime prevention, the private sector and academia, Cybercrime prevention by
internet service and hosting providers.
James Tetteh, A.-N., Williams, P., 2008. Digital forensics and the legal system: A dilemma of our times. Available at:
http://ro.ecu.edu.au/adf/41/
Draft African Union Convention, Art. 3-53; COMESA Draft Model Bill, Arts. 33-35; Commonwealth Model Law, Art.17; Council
of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 16; ECOWAS Draft Directive, Art. 33; ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts,
Art.23; League of Arab States Convention, Art. 23.
127
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents