stored computer data; (iii) powers for real-time collection of data; and (iv) powers for ensuring
expedited preservation of data.
In addition to the legal basis of such powers, two further issues require consideration – (a)
the limits and safeguards that should be applied to such powers; and (b) the use of investigative
powers in practice. The next section of this Chapter examines limits and safeguards through the lens
of international human rights standards on privacy. Subsequent sections of the Chapter consider use
of investigative measures in practice.
5.3 Privacy and investigative measures
KEY RESULTS:
Almost all responding countries report that privacy-based protections are applicable in
the context of computer data and electronic communications
Countries report the existence of a wide range of safeguards for the protection of
privacy during law enforcement investigations, including restrictions on data that can be
accessed, time limits, ‘probable cause’ requirements, and prosecutorial and judicial
oversight
International human rights law sets out clear protections for the privacy rights of
persons subject to law enforcement investigations. Core principles include that
investigative powers must give a clear indication of the conditions and circumstances
under which measures may be used, together with effective guarantees against abuse
The development of cloud computing introduces a high degree of uncertainty for users
concerning the privacy regime that will apply to their data, and the circumstances under
which privacy may legitimately be infringed for the purposes of law enforcement
investigations or security surveillance
Human rights and law enforcement investigations
International human rights law has a specific concern for the manner in which the state
achieves its crime prevention and criminal justice goals.70 All aspects of the investigation and
prosecution of crime have the potential to engage human rights standards, and criminal procedure law
and practice therefore come under particular scrutiny from international human rights law. 71
A range of rights potentially apply to law enforcement investigations – including rights to
liberty and security of person, and rights to fair trial.72 Often, however, challenges in this area are
founded on privacy-based protections within international and national law. All of the ICCPR, ECHR
and ACHR contain prohibitions on arbitrary interference with privacy, family, home and
correspondence.73 The scope of ‘privacy’ under international law is broad74 and case law is clear that
the intrusive nature of criminal investigations will engage privacy-based rights75 – including where a
70
71
72
73
74
75
United Nations Commission on Narcotic Drugs and Commission on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice. 2010. Drug control,
crime prevention and criminal justice: A Human Rights perspective. Note by the Executive Director. E/CN.7/2010/CRP.6 –
E/CN.15/2010/CRP.1., 3 March 2010.
Colvin, M., and Cooper, J. (eds.) 2009. Human Rights in the Investigation and Prosecution of Crime. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
ICCPR, Arts. 9 and 14.
ICCPR, Art. 17; ECHR, Art. 8; ACHR, Art. 11.
See for example, United Nations Human Rights Committee. 1988. General Comment No. 16: The right to respect of privacy, family, home
and correspondence, and protection of honour and reputation, 8 April 1998.
See for example, United Nations Human Rights Committee. Communication CCPR/C/82/D/903/1999; IACtHR Tristán Donoso.
Judgement of 27 January 2009; and ECtHR Application No’s 35394/97 and 13710/88.
134
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents