ordered by law enforcement authorities, as compared with more intrusive measures.93 Over 80 per
cent of responding countries, for example, stated that intrusive measures such as orders for content
data or real-time collection of data, required authorization by a prosecutor or by the courts, rather
than directly by law enforcement officers. Nonetheless, a small number of countries reported that
law enforcement authorities were able to authorize such investigations – raising potential concerns
over the sufficiency of safeguards for these measures. One country in the Americas, for example,
reported that an article of its procedural law, which had provided for interception in exceptional
circumstances without a warrant, had been declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court.94
Assessing safeguards through a human rights lens
Case law from international human rights courts and tribunals emphasizes that procedural
protections are critical to respecting privacy in the context of law enforcement investigations. The
table shows the core international right to privacy provisions, as well as human rights decisions
related to issues such as the absence of authorizing legislation for investigative measures; legislative
safeguards; and the use of investigative measures in practice. To date, few international human rights
decisions have directly addressed law enforcement cybercrime investigations.95
One important judgement of the ECtHR has, however, considered the balance of privacy
and law enforcement investigations. In the context of an online content offence involving a minor,
law enforcement agencies were unable to obtain subscriber
Although freedom of expression and
confidentiality of communications are primary
considerations and users of telecommunications
and Internet services must have a guarantee that
their own privacy and freedom of expression will
be respected, such guarantee cannot be absolute
and must yield on occasion to other legitimate
imperatives, such as the prevention of disorder or
crime… It is the task of the legislator to provide
the framework for reconciling the various claims
which compete for protection in this context.
ECtHR Application No. 2872/02
data from an ISP due to
confidentiality protections contained
in the telecommunications law. The
Court found that this prevented
effective steps from being taken to
identify
and
prosecute
the
96
perpetrator.
93
94
95
96
International human rights law provisions
ICCPR, Article 17, ECHR Article 8, ACHR Article 11
[No one shall be subjected to arbitrary or unlawful interference
with his privacy, family, home or correspondence (ICCPR)]
[Everyone has the right to respect for his private and family life, his
home and his correspondence (ECHR)] [No one may be the object
of arbitrary or abusive interference with his private life, his family,
his home, or his correspondence (ACHR)]
Absence of authorizing legislation for investigative measures
ECtHR Application No. 8691/79
In the absence of legal rules, the practice of voluntary supply by a
telecommunications service provider of records of telephone
numbers dialled and call duration, upon request, to police when
‘essential for police enquiries and in relation to serious crime’ was
found to be incompatible with the right to privacy. The Court
highlighted the absence of legal rules concerning the scope and
manner of exercise of the discretion.
ECtHR Application No. 47114/99
The interception of pager messages by law enforcement using a
‘clone’ of a suspect’s personal pager in the absence of laws
regulating the interception of page messages was found to be
incompatible with the right to privacy. The Court noted that
domestic law must provide protection against arbitrary interference
with the right to privacy.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Although the ECtHR, for example, has considered the monitoring of email and internet usage in an employment context. See
ECtHR Application No. 62617/00. In this case, the Court applied the tests of identifying whether there was an interference with
privacy and (finding so), whether the interference was in accordance with the law.
ECtHR Application No. 2872/02.
138
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents