CHAPTER FIVE: LAW ENFORCEMENT AND INVESTIGATIONS
Private sector perspectives
Information gathering for the Study also included the collection of information from
private sector organizations regarding perspectives on, and experience of, cooperation with law
enforcement authorities. Private sector organizations that completed the Study questionnaire
reported a range of internal polices and external obligations concerning domestic and foreign law
enforcement data requests. In addition, many private sector polices are publicly available in the form
of ‘law enforcement handbooks’ that provide guidance on data retention polices and frameworks for
law enforcement requests.132
In response to the Study questionnaire, many law enforcement authorities highlighted
challenges regarding short data retention times by private sector organizations and service
providers.133 With a view to providing information on retention practice, the table below provides
information from a sample of private sector retention and law enforcement access policies. The
table demonstrates that a range of data are generated and stored during the provision of computing
and electronic communication services. It also shows divergent data retention policies for these
different types of data – giving a strong indication of the challenges faced by law enforcement and
private sector organizations in identifying and securing appropriate information for use in evidence.
None of the service providers reviewed, for example, retained identical information for identical
time periods. Publicly available retention periods ranged from as little as one day to indefinitely.
Some information appeared to only be retained during the period in which the subscriber account
remained active. A number of private sector organizations indicated that responding to law
enforcement requests can be time-consuming and not always easily accomplished due to storage and
records retention protocols and policies. The availability of sufficient personnel to respond requests
may also hamper compliance or its timeliness. For smaller organizations, compliance with law
enforcement requests appears to be more burdensome in terms of expenditures of personnel and
resources.134
Private sector organization data storage and retention
Company
Types of data produced
Data retention period
Communication
and Information
Services Provider
#1
Chat room dialogue
Instant messenger conversations
Member directory logs
Email IP/connection access logs
Group IP logs
Internet connection access logs
Requirement of
a formal
request for
disclosure
None
Yes
60 days
TV phone (ANI) connection logs
Communication
and Information
Services Provider
132
133
134
IP connection history records
60 days
90 days (Private)/60 days
(Groups)
Transactional data
Yes
See, for example, https://www.facebook.com/safety/groups/law/guidelines/ ;
http://pages.ebay.com/securitycenter/LawEnforcementCenter.html ; http://support.twitter.com/articles/41949-guidelines-forlaw-enforcement# ; and http://myspace.desk.com/customer/portal/articles/526170-law-enforcement-support
See Chapter Eight (Prevention), Section 8.3 Cybercrime prevention, the private sector and academia, Cybercrime prevention by
internet service and hosting providers.
Study cybercrime interviews (private sector).
147
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents