CHAPTER FIVE: LAW ENFORCEMENT AND INVESTIGATIONS
legislative or regulatory requirements.’135 Private sector organizations referred frequently to customer
terms of service use, and to privacy considerations. Nonetheless, private sector organizations
highlighted, in particular, that they should respond rapidly and positively where ‘life is at risk’, but
also noted that ‘is very, very rare.’136 Responding private sector organizations, including service
providers, drew a clear distinction between formal legal requirements to provide data, and informal
requests. Almost all responding corporations reported that they ‘must’ and ‘do’ respond to formal
domestic court orders to produce information ‘according to applicable laws’137 and ‘in accordance with our
legal responsibilities.’138 Upon receiving a request, for example, one private sector organization reported
that the first step is to identify ‘if there is an underlying statutory right to request the information or there is a
statutory disclosure obligation to provide information and to seek to ensure we do not violate any other laws or
company’s contractual obligations to clients’ and customer privacy.’139
The majority of private sector organizations reported that they did not consider themselves
to be under any obligation to provide data in response to an ‘informal’ request – such as a telephone
call – from law enforcement authorities. Although a number of organizations reported that they may
choose to provide data voluntary to informal requests in accordance with their own internal polices.
One international corporation noted, for example that it could respond to such requests ‘if the data is
available and providing it is in accordance with company legal and human resource regulations.’140 A larger number
of organizations reported that they could provide data in response to a ‘formal’ law enforcement
request – such as an official letter. Almost all, however, indicated that this was not an absolute
obligation and data could only be provided under certain conditions, such as where ‘there is a statutory
obligation to provide information and the disclosure does not violate other laws or company contractual obligations.’141
International corporations and national service providers frequently reported the
appointment of law enforcement focal points in order to facilitate cooperation with law
enforcement authorities. These included in-house CSIRT, IT security, legal, risk management, or
security departments. Other companies have cross-disciplinary teams or task forces to manage
relationships with law enforcement. Some private sector organizations reported that mechanisms for
strengthening cooperation and information exchange with law enforcement were still in the course
of development.142 Such mechanisms were viewed as important in light of an increasing number of
law enforcement requests for data from service providers. One multinational telecommunications
operator, for example, reported a 50-fold increase in the number of formal requests for computer
data received between the years 2008 and 2010.143
Private sector organizations also highlighted the fact that they often received both domestic
and foreign law enforcement requests. Many corporations reported that they only considered foreign
law enforcement requests where made through formal national channels.144 Some corporations, stated,
for example, that foreign law enforcement authorities are required to obtain an order for data from a
national court, through a mutual legal assistance request. Corporations with offices in multiple
countries reported that different national operations would always need to take into account local
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
Study cybercrime questionnaire (private sector). Q24.
Study cybercrime questionnaire (private sector). Q26.
Study cybercrime questionnaire (private sector). Q24-27.
Study cybercrime questionnaire (private sector). Q24.
Study cybercrime questionnaire (private sector). Q24-27.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire (private sector). Q30.
Study cybercrime questionnaire (private sector). Q35.
Study cybercrime questionnaire (private sector). Q28.
149
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents