Others, however, seemed to indicate that individual customer data could be supplied to law
enforcement authorities through such arrangements.159 While durable and efficient relationships
between law enforcement and service providers can greatly assist effective cybercrime investigations,
it is critical that such arrangements also meet rule of law and international human rights standards.
As discussed in this Chapter, these include sufficient clarity on the conditions and circumstances in
which law enforcement authorities are empowered to obtain computer data, and adequate and
effective guarantees against abuse.160 Arrangements similar, for example, to unfettered law
enforcement ‘terminal’ access to subscriber, traffic or content data stored by service providers may
be subject to particular levels of human rights scrutiny.161
5.6 Law enforcement capacity
KEY RESULTS:
Over 90 per cent of responding countries have begun to put in place specialized
structures for the investigation of cybercrime and crimes involving electronic evidence
In developing countries, however, these are not well resourced and suffer from a capacity
shortage
Countries with lower levels of development have significantly fewer specialized police,
with around 0.2 per 100,000 national internet users. The rates is two to five times higher
in more developed countries
Some 70 per cent of specialized law enforcement officers in less developed countries
were reported to lack computer skills and equipment
This section presents information gathered on the capacity of law enforcement authorities
to prevent and combat cybercrime. Institutional ‘capacity’ in the context of policing has a number of
elements, including strategic and operational capabilities, technical skills of personnel, and
sufficiency of officers and resources.162 Another important element of capacity is the degree of
‘specialization.’ Crimes that require a ‘specialized’ response are typically those that present specific
challenges in terms of offence definitions, applicability of laws, or evidence gathering and analysis.163
Cybercrime shows all of these characteristics, and a degree of law enforcement specialization is
critical to an effective crime prevention and criminal justice response. Law enforcement
specialization can occur at both the organizational and personnel levels – both of which often overlap.
While specialization will likely always be required in the area of cybercrime and electronic evidence,
it is also the case that – as the world advances towards hyperconnectivity – all law enforcement
officers will increasingly be expected to routinely handle and collect electronic evidence.
Organizational specialization
The majority of countries that responded to the Study questionnaire reported the existence
of specialized law enforcement structures for cybercrime. More than 75 per cent of countries
159
160
161
162
163
Ibid.
See above, Section 5.3 Privacy and investigative measures, Existence of privacy protections and procedural safeguards.
See, for example, http://www.edri.org/edri-gram/number6.24/bulgarian-administrative-case-data-retention
Katz, C.M., Maguire, E.R., Roncek, D.W., 2002. The Creation of Specialized Police Gang Units. Policing, 25(3):472-506.
Mace, R.R., 1999. Prosecution Organizations and the Network of Computer Crime Control. (Doctoral dissertation). AAT 9920188.
152
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents