CHAPTER SIX: ELECTRONIC EVIDENCE AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE
before it is possible to read it out in the main hearing.’48 Some countries also emphasized that ‘only the relevant
part of the collected evidence is transferred to prosecutors – irrelevant material or data is stored with the police.’49
Countries also provided details on a number of forms and means by which electronic
evidence might be presented in court. These included through testimony delivered by police officers;
through testimony delivered by forensic practitioners, including presentation of digital information
on projectors and widescreen monitors; and through printouts identifying objects, documents,
photographs, logs, and screen captures.50 One country in Asia focused on the use of expert reports,
noting that ‘Usually written reports are presented with explanations concerning the technical data.’ Other
countries recounted the presentation of electronic evidence on computer screens: ‘In a sophisticated
computer crime case, the user of a projector in court, as a way of screening the evidence, has provide itself as an efficient
way to pass the information from the prosecution to the court.’51
Still others reported multiple means of presentation. One country in Europe, for example,
noted that presentation of electronic evidence in court ‘Depends on the actual state and place of the evidence.
[electronic evidence may be introduced as] hardcopy prints, digital media (hard drives, CD, DVD, flash drives),
laptop or desktop presentations, remote presentations and [live] access in rare cases.’ Some countries, however,
highlighted that courtrooms were not typically set up for the use of technology in criminal trials.
One country in the Americas, for instance, reported that ‘Electronic trials are not yet common place. Not all
courtrooms are wired for the purpose of allowing the [State] to present its case electronically. Currently the [State] must
obtain the consent of the judge and defence counsel to use technology in the courtroom.’52
Very few countries reported the existence of special evidentiary laws governing electronic
evidence. For those that did, laws concerned areas such as legal assumptions concerning ownership
or authorship of electronic data and documents, as well as circumstances in which electronic
evidence may be considered authentic.53 Other countries provided information on the way in which
‘traditional’ rules of evidence may be interpreted in the context of electronic evidence. One country
from Oceania, for example, clarified how the ‘hearsay’ rule applied to electronic evidence in its
jurisdiction: ‘For electronic evidence specifically, the hearsay rule would not apply if the information contained in the
electronic evidence relates to a communication which was transmitted between computers and has been admitted in order
to identify the sender, receiver, date and time of the transmission.’54 Another country also noted that a ‘general
presumption’ exists that ‘where evidence that has been produced by a machine or other device is tendered, if the device
is one that, if properly used, ordinarily produces that outcome, it is taken that the device was working properly when it
produced the evidence.’55
Finally, countries reported on the ways in which electronic evidence could be used to
establish a link between a criminal act and a specific perpetrator. The nature of cybercrime means
that a mediating device, in the form of a computer system, is usually situated between the perpetrator
and the victim – leading to challenges in attribution of acts to specific persons. In cases where a
defendant is prosecuted, for example, for possession of illegal computer content, it must be
established that the content was knowingly placed on the device by the defendant, and not by
another person with access to the device. In this respect, one country commented that:
‘Circumstantial evidence will often be the only means by which to establish identification of who is speaking or
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q143.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q150.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q147.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q146.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q143.
167
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents