persons brought into formal contact, persons prosecuted and persons convicted for four cybercrime
acts in one country in Eastern Europe, alongside equivalent data for the ‘conventional’ crimes of
rape and homicide. The data confirm the picture of a higher number of suspects per recorded
offence for child pornography offences than other cybercrime acts. This pattern is repeated for
another content-related offence – that of computer-related copyright or trademark offences. In
general, however, all cybercrime offences show far fewer persons prosecuted or convicted than for
the conventional crimes. For the reporting country, cybercrime convictions represent, on average,
10 per cent of police-recorded offences, compared to around 80 per cent for rape and homicide.
The pattern demonstrates that the large number of cybercrime prosecution challenges
referred to by responding countries are borne out in the reality of lower conviction rates for
cybercrime offences – at least for this one example country. As discussed in the following section of
this Chapter, in many developing countries, the prosecution of cybercrime offences faces the
challenge not only of transnational evidence gathering and perpetrator obfuscation, but also of
prosecutorial and judicial capacity and specialization limitations.
6.4 Criminal justice capacity
Key Results:
Levels of prosecutorial cybercrime specialization are lower than for law enforcement
authorities. Around 60 per cent of all responding countries have put in place specialized
prosecutorial structures for cybercrime
Developed countries show higher levels of prosecutorial specialization than developing
countries
Over 60 per cent of lesser developed countries reported that specialized prosecutors
either had basic or no IT skills, and intermediate computer equipment or none at all
Courts show minimal levels of specialization for cybercrime, with just 10 per cent of
countries reporting specialized judicial services. The vast majority of cases are handled
by non-specialized judges, who, in 40 per cent of responding countries do not receive
any form of cybercrime-related training
In the same way as cybercrime and electronic evidence-based investigations require
specialization within law enforcement, the prosecution and adjudication of cybercrime cases also
calls for specialization within the criminal justice system. Such specialization requires personnel that
have an understanding of concepts of computing and the internet, a knowledge of cybercrime
legislative frameworks, and the ability to present and understand electronic evidence in court.
This section presents information reported by countries on the capacity of prosecutors and
courts to prosecute and adjudicate cybercrime. As in Chapter Five (Law enforcement and
investigations), institutional ‘capacity’ has a number of elements, including strategic and operational
capabilities, technical skills of personnel, and sufficiency of personnel and resources; as well as
degree of specialization. The point made in Chapter Five concerning an increasing need for all law
enforcement officers to routinely handle and collect electronic evidence equally applies to
prosecutors and judges. As the digital world advances, it may become hard to image the adjudication
of any offence without the presentation and consideration of electronic evidence.
172
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents