CHAPTER SIX: ELECTRONIC EVIDENCE AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE Organizational specialization Country responses to the Study questionnaire show that the degree of organizational cybercrime specialization for prosecution authorities is significantly less than that reported for law enforcement agencies. Whereas more than 90 per cent of countries reported some degree of cybercrime specialization within law enforcement, this proportion drops to around 60 per cent for prosecution authorities, across all responding countries.80 This figure conceals, however, significant differences according to levels of country development. Almost 80 per cent of more highly developed countries report some form of prosecutorial cybercrime specialization. Around half of these countries have a specialized unit, while the other half have either a specialized agency, another specialized unit (such as for organized crime), or specialized personnel who are not organized in a separate unit. In contrast, less than 60 per cent of less developed countries report prosecutorial cybercrime specialization. In the majority of these, the degree of specialization is at the level of a specialized Figure 6.8: Prosecution structure for preventing and combatting cybercrime unit. 100% Specialized Agency 90% For developed Specialized Unit 80% countries reporting Other Unit 70% organizational Special Skills 60% specialization, many Non‐specialists 50% indicated that a specialized 40% division or unit exists at the 30% federal, provincial or state 20% 10% level in the ministry of 0% justice or the national HDI <.8 HDI >.8 prosecution agency, (n=21) (n=18) frequently overseeing, Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire Q157. (n=41) coordinating or supporting specialized units or generalists in field and local offices. Some countries also reported technical and investigatory support from ‘a dedicated team of police investigators, computer engineers and prosecutors that both investigate and prosecute cybercrime.’81 ‘In some cases, individual prosecution offices have special competences to deal with prominent sets of proceedings related to information and communication crime, and for cybercrime in the strict sense.’ Another developed country Figure 6.9: Court structure for cybercrime cases noted that: ‘There is some variation, but [a] small number of local offices Non‐specialized, general personnel 87% have specialized internet child exploitation teams.’82 Other specialized Unit In less developed countries, arrangements are often less established. One country in Africa reported that its newly established unit was tasked with prosecution ‘as well as advice on 80 81 82 6% Specialized personnel, No Unit 3% Specialized, dedicated Unit 3% Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q186. (n=31) Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q157. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q157. Ibid. 173

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents