policies and legislation, provide technical assistance to other prosecutors and law enforcement agencies, [but] as a new unit, training and equipment needs are yet to be met.’83 In some, there is a reported ‘lot of space for improvement.’ One country in Africa reported that ‘There are no prosecutors assigned to do cybercrime cases. Any prosecutor is required to cover cybercrime even those who have not been trained on cybercrime.’84 A few countries without specialized prosecution structures indicated plans to create a new prosecution structure for cybercrime. Such plans included proposals ‘to create a number of specialized units’ and ‘plans to create task forces in major cities that currently do not have specialized prosecution structures.’85 One country in Europe envisages creating ‘independent units in prosecutors’ offices with a great volume of activity and in the remaining offices to combine cyber specialized prosecutors with other types of specialized’86 units. Other countries reported no plans for a specialized unit, although some of these reported planning to integrate cyber-specialists into existing prosecutorial structures. Court structures show the least degree of specialization, with around 10 per cent of all responding countries reporting some degree of court cybercrime specialization. Only three per cent of all responding countries reported a specialized, dedicated cybercrime judicial unit. Some six per cent reported another type of specialized judicial unit, such as a commercial crimes court. Three per cent reported the judicial oversight of cybercrime cases by specialized judicial personnel. A few countries indicated that there are currently plans under way, either through legislation or administrative measures, to create specialized cybercrime courts or tribunals. In general, however, responding countries were of the view that they ‘do not generally involve specialized courts based on thematic subject matter, although some judges at various levels do specialize in criminal cases as a matter of practice, and may tend to have criminal cases assigned to them by Chief Justices.’87 Personnel specialization In the same way as prosecution structures show less organizational specialization for cybercrime than law enforcement, so countries also reported lower levels of technical capabilities amongst specialized prosecutors than Figure 6.10: Technical capabilities of police and prosecutors for law enforcement officers. Figure 6.10 shows country responses 60% 52% concerning law enforcement and 50% 88 prosecutorial IT skills. While very 41% few cybercrime prosecutors reported 40% 33% advanced IT skills compared with law 30% Police (n=54) enforcement officers specialized in 20% Prosecution (n=29) 20% cybercrime, this may, in part, reflect 15% the different functional roles of each. 7% 10% 6% 4% Although prosecutorial involvement in 0% investigations varies across legal Advanced IT Intermediate Basic IT Skills No IT Skills systems, in general, law enforcement Skills IT Skills Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q116 and Q160. (n=54, 29) officers may be more often required to conduct or supervise initial forensics investigations and collection of electronic evidence. 83 84 85 86 87 88 Ibid. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q160. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q157. Ibid. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q187. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q116 and Q160. 174

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents