CHAPTER SEVEN: INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION
CHAPTER SEVEN: INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION
This Chapter considers formal and informal international cooperation responses to the
transnational challenge of cybercrime. It finds that widespread reliance on slow-moving
traditional mechanisms such as mutual legal assistance, the emergence of country
cooperation clusters, and a lack of clarity on permissible direct law enforcement access
to extraterritorial data present challenges to an effective global response.
7.1 Sovereignty, jurisdiction and international cooperation
Key results:
A ‘transnational dimension’ to a cybercrime offence arises where an element or
substantial effect of the offence is another territory, or where part of the modus
operandi of the offence is in another territory
Countries responding to the Study questionnaire reported regional averages of
between 30 and 70 per cent of cybercrime acts that involve a transnational
dimension
This engages issues of sovereignty, jurisdiction, transnational investigations,
extraterritorial evidence, and a requirement for international cooperation
Cybercrime as a transnational crime
%
Cybercrime is by no means the first ‘new’ form of crime to demand a global response. Over
the past decades, global action has been required to address challenges such as illicit drug trafficking
and transnational organized crime, including
through the development of international
Figure 7.1: Percentage of cybercrime acts involving a
transnational dimension
agreements. Nonetheless, it has become a
90
truism that cybercrime today presents
80
unique international cooperation challenges.
70
During information gathering for the Study,
60
more than half of countries reported that
50
between 50 and 100 per cent of cybercrime
40
acts encountered by the police involved a
30
‘transnational element.’1 The figure shows that
20
countries in Europe perceived the highest
10
proportion of cybercrime acts involving a
0
transnational dimension. Countries in Africa
Europe (8)
Asia &
Africa (6)
Americas (7)
Oceania (7)
and the Americas perceived the lowest.2
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q83. (n=28)
One country from Eastern Europe noted that ‘around 80 per cent of the cybercrime acts inspected by
1
2
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q83. Some countries who could not provide exact numbers estimated the percentage to be ‘very
high.’
The figure shows median values with upper and lower quartiles represented by error bars.
183
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents